Insights into Rainwater's comment on MMSD's 80% success in reading

Ruth Robarts wrote, "In his memo [to reject $2 million in Reading First funds]Superintendent Rainwater argues that MMSD should refuse to make the proposed changes at the five schools because we are a "successful" district. He states that our reading program is a success because more than 80% of all third graders score at grade level or above ("proficient or advanced") on the Wisconsin Reading Comprehension Test. Unfortunately, that's not true for the schools that qualified for Reading First grants. As Rainwater admits, more than 30% of the third graders in these schools fell below "proficient or advanced" scores in recent years. See "Madison Superintendent Declines $2M in Federal Funds Without Consulting the Board" below."

The superintendent's interprestion of the 80% success rate doesn't seem to appreciate what Reading First consultants recommend for the other 20%.

To see what a complete reading program looks like, you can link to presentations by the Institute for the Development of Educational Achievement.

The presentation on the Center to Improve Reading Competence Using Intensive Treatments Schoolwide is especially revealing in showing how a reading program can address 80% of a school population, but the program needs a secondary prevention program to assist 15% of the school's kids and a tertiary intervention for the 5% with severe, sustained reading difficulty.

From my experience, the MMSD does not appear to have consistent, effective intervention for either the 15% or the 5%.

Ed Blume

Posted by Ed Blume at October 25, 2004 7:14 PM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas