Who Controls the Reading List?

Letters to the New York Times:

To the Editor:

As a university literature instructor, I found the idea of allowing middle-school students to choose their own reading lists disturbing.

Would we be so eager to embrace a "choose your own math" or "choose your own history" class?

The answer is no. We expect that students learn the curriculum in those courses whether or not they are "into it." Literature is no different, and literature courses shouldn't be treated as glorified book clubs.

By allowing students to bypass difficult texts or texts that don't seem to relate to their contemporary lives in favor of "Captain Underpants," teachers miss a valuable opportunity to teach them that real scholastic and intellectual growth often comes when we are most challenged and least comfortable.

Lisa Dunick
Champaign, Ill., Aug. 30, 2009

Posted by Jim Zellmer at September 8, 2009 1:32 AM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas