Half-Crazy, Half-True: Alfie Kohn's startling message on schools may be hurting Wisconsin's poorest students

Michael J. Petrilli:

One hundred years ago, a progressive populist barnstormed the country, delivering fiery speeches and railing against the gold standard. Today another progressive populist barnstorms the country, delivering fiery speeches and railing against academic standards. Meet Alfie Kohn, the William Jennings Bryan of our age.

The Badger State has always been friendly territory for progressive populists; Kohn is a perfect fit. He's been an influential voice in Wisconsin education discussions for nearly 20 years.

Kohn is a frequent guest on Wisconsin Public Radio, and his speeches have carried the imprimatur of everyone from the Wisconsin Association of School Boards to the University of Wisconsin-Madison School of Education to the Wisconsin Education Association Council to the Metropolitan Milwaukee Association of Commerce. Last November, his talk on the UW-Madison campus drew more than 700 people.

Like most demagogues, Kohn knows how to tap into his audience's raw emotions -- anger, feelings of powerlessness and resentment of a ruling elite. In his case, he puts voice to what many educators already believe: That school reform is a corporate plot to turn young people into docile employees; that an obsession with standardized testing is crowding out any real intellectual engagement in our schools; and that teachers have no say over what happens inside their own classrooms.

Posted by Jim Zellmer at March 19, 2012 8:02 PM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas