Gray Area: A transracial adoption teaches our writer that issues of race in the U.S. are anything but black and white.

Debra Monroe:

In the mid-1990s I set out to adopt a baby. I made phone calls to adoption agencies, and staff members asked warily if I'd consider a transracial adoption. I said yes. At one agency, the receptionist snapped: "Do you understand what transracial means?" Her tone startled me. "I think so," I said, parsing syllables, "adoption across races." Impatient, she said, "You'll get a black baby!"

I lived in a small town without internet access and had done my research--on adoption laws, policy, advice--at a library twenty miles away. I'd found references to a 1972 position paper issued by the National Association of Black Social Workers that objected to transracial adoption as "cultural genocide," an understandable position, given the state of race relations in 1972. The few agencies that had been doing black-white adoptions stopped because of the position paper. I didn't find references to a time when agencies started doing transracial adoptions again because the Metzenbaum Act--passed in 1994 to address the fact that children of color were overrepresented in the child welfare system--had been amended, making "race-matching" as the sole determinant for the placement of a child unambiguously illegal.

Some staff members welcomed the change but weren't sure if adoptive parents would. Other staff members objected to the change--take the receptionist who'd thought I must not know what transracial meant based on my answer. In the end, I used an agency whose staff members were able to discuss race without anger or recoil.

Posted by Jim Zellmer at April 11, 2012 1:01 AM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas