The decline and fall of America's literary ecosystem

Christopher Caldwell:

This week the Pulitzer Prize board deemed the latest crop of American novels and short-story collections not up to scratch. Asked to choose between the late David Foster Wallace's The Pale King, Denis Johnson's Train Dreams and Karen Russell's Swamplandia!, the judges answered: none of the above. Since the prize was established in 1917 there have been 10 other years when no book got the nod, but it hadn't happened since 1977. The publishing industry is reeling from the impact of ebooks. Editors and writers needed a morale-booster.

The novelist Ann Patchett complained in The New York Times that most readers would "just figure it was a bum year for fiction" - and would be wrong. Her fellow novelist Doug Magee, by contrast, declared himself "ecstatic". He wrote: "The prize only serves to heighten and concentrate a hierarchy built primarily on promotion." In this view, the judges' demurral looks like a victory for standards. But the situation is probably more dire than Ms Patchett or Mr Magee realise.

Posted by Jim Zellmer at April 22, 2012 3:27 AM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas