Losers in the education wars

Elliot Haspel:

The education debate in the United States has taken on a particularly nasty tone, and it's turning into a needless war. Sides are digging in, accusations are being launched and, sadly, children's lives are being negatively affected because we are too blind to see that this is all built on false choices.

The latest skirmish came in May, when author Diane Ravitch wrote on her blog that the executive director of Parent Revolution, Ben Austin, was "loathsome" for helping parents petition to remove their school's principal and that there was a "special place in hell" for Parent Revolution contributors. (Ravitch has since made an apology of sorts for the personal attacks.) The fire and brimstone does not come purely from one camp; prominent education reform supporter Whitney Tilson called Ravitch's remarks "thuggery" in an e-mail newsletter.

As a former teacher, what saddens me is that the sides draw battle lines where there need not be any. There is a sense that we are continually facing two doors: Address poverty factors or address school factors. Support standards or support teachers. Care about academic outcomes or care about the whole child. The ad nauseam this-or-that creates a house of mirrors that leaves us all turned around.

Posted by Jim Zellmer at August 10, 2013 2:46 AM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas