Free (UK) schools: our education system has been dismembered in pursuit of choice

Stephen Ball:

The English education system is being dismembered. Gradually but purposefully first New Labour and now the coalition government have been unpicking and disarticulating the national system of state schooling. With free schools and academies of various kinds, faith schools, studio schools and university technical colleges, the school system is beginning to resemble the patchwork of uneven and unequal provision that existed prior to the 1870 Education Act.

At the same time, we are moving back to an incoherent and haphazard jigsaw of providers - charities, foundations, social enterprises and faith and community groups - monitored at arm's length by the central state. Furthermore, private providers are waiting in the wings for the opportunity to profit from running schools.

Local democratic oversight has been almost totally displaced. Our relationship to schools is being modelled on that of the privatised utilities - we are individual customers, who can switch provider if we are unhappy, in theory, and complain to the national watchdog if we feel badly served - but with no direct, local participation or involvement, no say in our children's education.

These changes have been pursued in the name of choice, diversity and autonomy. Some parents now have new schools to choose from for their children, but some do not. This simply depends on where you live. You may have a local academy or you may not. If you do, it might be a sponsored academy (Bexley, south-east London), a chain academy (Ark, ULT, AET), a converter academy, or a school subject to forced academisation. There are 174 free schools and you may live near one of these, but many are faith schools or have specialisms that may not suit your child. The free schools were supposed to be targeted at areas of social disadvantage but recent research by Rob Higham at the Institute of Education indicates their distribution does not reflect this aim. There is a distribution map of free schools on the DfE website.Some of these free schools already have problems - unqualified teachers, poor management - as Nick Clegg will point out in his speech on Thursday. Academies seem to display the same diversity of outcomes as the schools they replaced. If you live in a rural area you're unlikely to have much, if any, choice of school.

Posted by Jim Zellmer at October 25, 2013 12:37 AM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas