School Information System

Greg Lukianoff:

One of the ingenious compromises they came up with for dealing with beliefs that exist outside rational examination appears in two of the most brilliant parts of the First Amendment: the Free Exercise Clause, which says you can believe whatever non-falsifiable doctrine you wish, paired with the Establishment Clause, which says you may not mandate belief in your non-falsifiable system for everyone else.

But what do we do in a situation where so much of what we call ideology has essentially taken the place of religion, and too many of us—especially in academia, but also outside it—hold non-falsifiable beliefs and wish to impose them on reality? There is no clear way to distinguish those rigid beliefs from any others, because they do not call themselves religion or faith. I know people have proposed something like an Establishment Clause for ideology, but I don’t see how that could possibly work in practice. All future debates would just turn into each side trying to prove that the other guy’s belief system, but not their own, is religion-like ideology. Naturally, their own view would simply be “truth.” I’ve been puzzling over this a lot lately.

Truth-seeking simply cannot work in an environment where too many people are afraid to play devil’s advocate, engage in thought experimentation, and take seriously the possibility that they might be wrong on the most important issues. Such an environment simply becomes a dogma factory, where people are motivated to rationalize whatever their tribe wishes to be true.

Brooks:

Milwaukee received $772 million in ESSER funding and just passed a $252 million referendum (which Mandela Barnes publicly supported).

When the largest district in the state can’t fix its air conditioning, the issue isn’t a lack of funding. The issue is the priorities of the adults in charge.

———

2026-2027 Madison K-12 $pending continues to grow, fueled by a 9.7% (!) property tax increase. Total spending will be at least $706,000,000 for 25,003 students, or $28,236 per student.

May 2026 Madison School District Presentation: 7,095 adults for 25,003 students (3.52 students per adult!)

Early Literacy Screener Map.

More. Act 20.

3,887 Madison 4 year old to third grade students scored lower than 75% of the students in the national comparison group.

Madison taxpayers have long supported far above average k-12 tax & $pending. This despite our long term, disastrous reading results. May, 2026: 7,095 Staff for 25,003 students; $pending > $26k per student!

Madison Schools: More $, No Accountability

The taxpayer funded Madison School District long used Reading Recovery…

The data clearly indicate that being able to read is not a requirement for graduation at (Madison) East, especially if you are black or Hispanic”

A.B.T.: “Ain’t been taught.”

My Question to Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers on Teacher Mulligans and our Disastrous Reading Results

2017: West High Reading Interventionist Teacher’s Remarks to the School Board on Madison’s Disastrous Reading Results 

Madison’s taxpayer supported K-12 school district, despite spending far more than most, has long tolerated disastrous reading results.

“An emphasis on adult employment”

Wisconsin Public Policy Forum Madison School District Report[PDF]

WEAC: $1.57 million for Four Wisconsin Senators

Friday Afternoon Veto: Governor Evers Rejects AB446/SB454; an effort to address our long term, disastrous reading results

Booked, but can’t read (Madison): functional literacy, National citizenship and the new face of Dred Scott in the age of mass incarceration.

When A Stands for Average: Students at the UW-Madison School of Education Receive Sky-High Grades. How Smart is That?

Arthur Jones IIJun 8, 2026

Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La., is introducing a proposal on Monday that aims to improve reading outcomes for America’s youth and combat illiteracy nationwide.

The Reading Excellence and Achievement for Development — or “READ” — Act focuses on evidence-based reading instruction, implementation and intervention through a growing practice called the “science of reading.”

…….

Education advocates are calling the READ Act the largest federal reading reform proposal in years. If passed, the bipartisan bill would use a combination of foundational literacy components, including phonemic awareness, fluency, language structure, vocabulary, background knowledge and literacy knowledge to teach reading, according to the bill’s text.

The bill requires state grantees to craft literacy instruction plans aligned with the science of reading.

Critics warn that there is no one-size-fits-all solution to the literacy crisis. Some experts suggest reading to children — and incorporating a balanced literacy approach — should also be employed to help students achieve better results.

With multiple Democratic co-sponsors, including New Hampshire Senator Maggie Hassan and Colorado Senator John Hickenlooper, the bill is expected to make it out of Cassidy’s committee and could receive a floor vote.

The reading crisis is widespread. Only 35% of 8th-grade students were proficient in reading in 2024, according to the National Assessment of Educational Progress.

——-

Early Literacy Screener Map.

More. Act 20.

3,887 Madison 4 year old to third grade students scored lower than 75% of the students in the national comparison group.

Madison taxpayers have long supported far above average k-12 tax & $pending. This despite our long term, disastrous reading results. May, 2026: 7,095 Staff for 25,003 students; $pending > $26k per student!

Madison Schools: More $, No Accountability

The taxpayer funded Madison School District long used Reading Recovery…

The data clearly indicate that being able to read is not a requirement for graduation at (Madison) East, especially if you are black or Hispanic”

A.B.T.: “Ain’t been taught.”

My Question to Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers on Teacher Mulligans and our Disastrous Reading Results

2017: West High Reading Interventionist Teacher’s Remarks to the School Board on Madison’s Disastrous Reading Results 

Madison’s taxpayer supported K-12 school district, despite spending far more than most, has long tolerated disastrous reading results.

“An emphasis on adult employment”

Wisconsin Public Policy Forum Madison School District Report[PDF]

WEAC: $1.57 million for Four Wisconsin Senators

Friday Afternoon Veto: Governor Evers Rejects AB446/SB454; an effort to address our long term, disastrous reading results

Booked, but can’t read (Madison): functional literacy, National citizenship and the new face of Dred Scott in the age of mass incarceration.

When A Stands for Average: Students at the UW-Madison School of Education Receive Sky-High Grades. How Smart is That?

Rebecca Noel:

Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools has spent nearly a decade and millions of dollars incorporating technology into the school day. But now parents are pushing back.

CMS wants $6 million from Mecklenburg County in its 2026-27 budget proposal for refreshing student devices. It’s not the first request of that kind: CMS has budgeted around $16 million to $20 million in county funding to update student devices over four years, beginning in 2024.

Under former Superintendent Clayton Wilcox, CMS began rolling out a one-to-one device program in 2018, meaning every student would eventually have their own Chromebook to take to and from school each day.

That became essential during the COVID-19 pandemic, as instruction moved online. By the 2021-2022 school year, 96 percent of U.S. public schools reported giving digital devices to students who needed them, according to data from the National Center for Education Statistics.

But now parents — and one county commissioner — are questioning the role technology plays in learning.

“I recognize that the world is different than when I graduated high school, but I think that we should consider spending less money on tech,” Mecklenburg County Commissioner Leigh Altman told CMS officials at a May 13 budget meeting.

Eugene Volokh:

Eli McKown-Dawson (Silver Bulletin) writes (introduced by Nate Silver):

California is notoriously slow at counting its ballots. In 2024, it took California until November 8 (three days after Election Day) to get just 70 percent of its ballots counted. Across all 50 states, the average share of the vote counted by that date was more than 95 percent, putting California squarely in last place. Rest assured, The Golden State did eventually hit that 95 percent mark … a full 10 days later….

Florida now manages to count 99 percent of its ballots within a few hours of polls closing, in part because election officials can process ballots before the polls close. And they are able to accomplish this feat of incredible speed with a sizable proportion of mail votes — about 27 percent in 2024…. Colombia held a presidential election on Sunday, and 99.98 percent of the result was in on Monday morning. Japan also counts most of its votes overnight. And in the UK (not exactly a poster child for state capacity), you can generally expect to have calls for all 650 parliamentary seats the morning after the election….

Nor is the problem inherent in California’s choice to promote mail voting:

——

Meet Doris, she lives in California and is registered as a 126 year old who has voted in 51 elections and has NO IDEA. California’s voting system is so corrupt that by simply knocking on the door of the “126 year old” proves election fraud.

——-

Rick Esenberg:

Having done a study of the 2020 election in WI, I know proving fraud directly is very difficult. So you look for anomalies. The CA break for the third place candidate might very well be one. I think this election will destroy any possibility of a national popular vote for President. I don’t know if there is fraud in CA. But I don’t trust it enough to allow it to determine who will be President.

WWW link:

A digital archive of Admiral Hyman G. Rickover’s speeches and memos

Admiral Hyman Rickover, also known as the “Father of the Nuclear Navy”, built the first nuclear-powered submarineand civilian nuclear reactor.

As the U.S. returns once more to an era of shipbuilding and building nuclear energy infrastructure, understanding Rickover’s management methods is of even greater importance.

This website is a searchable digital archive of Admiral Hyman G. Rickover’s speeches, congressional testimonies, and memos. It includes over 2,500 pages of documents, including over 1,800 pages of never before seen digitized artifacts from the U.S. Naval Academy Archives

Jennifer Valentino-DeVries:

TikTok gave the National PTA millions of dollars, in part to throw school events about online safety and provide favorable comments to journalists.

The documents emerged from lawsuits filed by more than 1,400 school districts against Meta, Snap, TikTok and YouTube amid a rising backlash against social media, with parent movements and best-selling books blaming the platforms for loneliness, bullying, eating disorders and sexual exploitation.

The outcry, long focused on social media’s harm to mental health, has now shifted to its upending of the classroom. Many school districts are banning smartphones, and some are re-evaluating their reliance on devices like Chromebooks, the inexpensive laptops made by YouTube’s parent company, Google.

Bill Glahn:

Recently, I’ve had the opportunity to dig into the secret case files of dozens of illegal alien habeas corpus cases filed in federal district court in Minnesota. The hidden files reveal a judicial system far more broken than you can imagine.

The habeas corpus petitions are filed as civil cases on behalf of illegal aliens who are being held in ICE custody in anticipation of their upcoming deportation. The number of cases filed skyrocketed during Operation Metro Surge earlier this year. The filing pace has dropped off (but not stopped) since the surge wound down.

So far in 2026, nearly 1,300 habeas cases have been filed in Minnesota. Most of these cases include noncitizens from Mexico and Central and South America. There are some from southeast Asia and more from Africa (both east and west). A tiny handful hail from eastern Europe.

From that number we’ve had a handful of repeat customers, whose original petitions were denied or who have been re-detained after being released.

Until late March, these petitions were nearly always successful in gaining the release of the detained alien. But then on March 25, the 8th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals ruled that the applicable law reads “shall be detained” and that the law really does indeed apply.

As I’ve documented during the past two months, a few local judges have followed the law, but the majority of district court judges have invented ways to circumvent the 8th Circuit. In any event, the success rate has dropped considerably, but not down to zero.

The Economist:

You are having too many babies. For decades that crude message was drilled into the minds of Indians by their rulers, abetted by inept foreign donors. In the 1960s slogans on school buildings chided parents, telling them: “Two or three children, enough”. By the 1970s officials had taken a crueller turn, overseeing the sterilisation of millions of young adults, usually the poor, many forcibly. But when Indian school textbooks are reprinted this summer, they will carry a very different message. They will warn not of the dangers of having too many babies, but of the risks of having too few.

——

Choose life.

Corri Hess:

Members of the Milwaukee Reading Coalition say the Department of Public Instruction promised to help fund an initiative to train teachers in early literacy, but has reneged and the project is now in jeopardy. 

Fewer than 10 percent of children in kindergarten through third grade attending both private and public schools in Milwaukee are meeting reading targets.  

In May 2025, Milwaukee Public Schools, charter schools, private schools, philanthropic and business groups came together to create the Reading Coalition. 

The group wanted to raise an undisclosed amount of private and public money to do three things: train early education teachers and principals in Milwaukee on the science of reading, pay for the training materials, and give a $1,500 stipend to educators who completed the training. 

Long-time education activist Howard Fuller has been leading the charge. 

He says DPI has repeatedly indicated there was a pathway to support the work through literacy grant funding. Based on those assurances, the coalition secured private donations and recruited an executive leader, Fuller said. 

But DPI has abruptly changed course, Fuller said. 

“We got rolled, gaslighted, whatever term you want to use,” Fuller said. 

———

Early Literacy Screener Map.

More. Act 20.

3,887 Madison 4 year old to third grade students scored lower than 75% of the students in the national comparison group.

Madison taxpayers have long supported far above average k-12 tax & $pending. This despite our long term, disastrous reading results. May, 2026: 7,095 Staff for 25,003 students; $pending > $26k per student!

Madison Schools: More $, No Accountability

The taxpayer funded Madison School District long used Reading Recovery…

The data clearly indicate that being able to read is not a requirement for graduation at (Madison) East, especially if you are black or Hispanic”

A.B.T.: “Ain’t been taught.”

My Question to Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers on Teacher Mulligans and our Disastrous Reading Results

2017: West High Reading Interventionist Teacher’s Remarks to the School Board on Madison’s Disastrous Reading Results 

Madison’s taxpayer supported K-12 school district, despite spending far more than most, has long tolerated disastrous reading results.

“An emphasis on adult employment”

Wisconsin Public Policy Forum Madison School District Report[PDF]

WEAC: $1.57 million for Four Wisconsin Senators

Friday Afternoon Veto: Governor Evers Rejects AB446/SB454; an effort to address our long term, disastrous reading results

Booked, but can’t read (Madison): functional literacy, National citizenship and the new face of Dred Scott in the age of mass incarceration.

When A Stands for Average: Students at the UW-Madison School of Education Receive Sky-High Grades. How Smart is That?

Foundation for Individual Rights & Expression:

• Date: June 9, 2026
• Location:Online

For generations, critics have argued that academia leans too heavily in one political direction. A new analysis from FIRE takes a closer look at the data behind these claims. Join University of Rochester professor David Primo and FIRE Research Fellow Nathan Honeycutt for a timely conversation on the newly released research examining faculty political viewpoints. This webinar is open to al

US Department of Justice:

As part of the resolution, Cleveland Clinic has committed $2 million to provide restorative care for detransitioners—the very victims of these predatory and dangerous practices—regardless of their insured status or ability to pay.  

The agreements come less than a month after the Justice Department announced its resolution with Texas Children’s Hospital (“Texas Children’s”), which the Department secured through a partnership with Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. As previously announced, Texas Children’s agreed to pay a $10,000,000 penalty, and, much like Cleveland Clinic’s commitment today, create the first-of-its-kind clinic dedicated to treating detransitioners. Texas Children’s also agreed to permanently cease providing any sex-rejecting procedures to minors.

These historic commitments pair the cessation of these dangerous practices masquerading as medical treatment with substantial investments in remediating the destruction they cause and restoring the health of the victims.

By Russell Samora. Design & Illustration by Shelly Tan.

Above are real results from my extensive analysis of this specific form of simile. Once you start looking, you see them everywhere, from the classics like Jane Eyre to last year’s darling Heart the Lover.

Neetu Arnold:

Universities have let progressive dogma degrade their academic missions, eviscerating public faith in higher education. College leaders willing to admit this truth are rare. Vanderbilt University chancellor Daniel Diermeier is one. He has long been a champion of political neutralityand has called out the politicization of scholarly associations—approaches other university leaders are only now catching up on.

Further, Diermeier has stood firm when students, faculty, or staff violate academic norms. After the October 7 Hamas attacks, campuses across the United States saw illegal encampments, vandalism, and unrest. Vanderbilt, by contrast, maintained order by swiftly disciplining students who violated university codes.

Adopting these policies and principles can be challenging for university leaders, partly because they fear how their own faculty or academic departments might respond. Yet Diermeier’s love of universities emboldens him. In a recent interview, transcribed below, he told me that education and research are “noble work,” but only if they are grounded in core principles. And he emphasized how politicization in some departments overshadows the good work conducted in others.

With American higher education in crisis, Diermeier’s is a voice to listen to. This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

Quinton Klabon:

• staff down -747 since 2025, but did not keep up with student drop
• teachers soon to be <50% of school workforce
• major cause of referenda and low teacher pay

David Sacks

There’s just one problem. Nationalization of AI will accelerate the corporate-government fusion we’re already sliding toward. Conservatives rightly fear a Central Bank Digital Currency. They ought to be even more concerned about Central Government AI — a system with even more totalistic power over information, decision-making, and human behavior. We saw how social media was weaponized to censor conservatives (including President Trump) in the last Democrat administration. The definition of “trust & safety” expanded to mean protecting the public from supposed psychological harms, micro-aggressions, and disinformation (you know, like hearing conservative ideas or true facts about Covid). That “safety” agenda as applied to AI will be vastly more powerful and Orwellian. AI won’t just moderate posts; it will curate reality — with the ability to rewrite history, enforce ideological conformity, influence policy at scale, mass surveil Americans, and condition the benefits of the many systems it controls on approved behavior. America won’t win the AI race if we beat China but end up with a CCP-style social credit system in the U.S. — and that is the danger as the government becomes more deeply involved in AI development and assumes direct ownership and control.

Amy Borrett:

Overseas students starting at the University of Cambridge this autumn will pay at least £450,000 for a medicine degree as England’s top-ranking universities plan a 29 per cent rise in international undergraduate fees over four years.

The average tuition fee for an overseas undergraduate studying at the country’s leading universities is expected to increase to almost £34,700 by 2028-29, up 29 per cent from 2024-25, according to analysis by the FT.

While domestic students pay a fixed fee, the cost of tuition for those coming from abroad varies between subjects and institutions.

——-

Elite universities will soon become simply LVMH for ugly people.

Jordan Powell V

How a dubious proposition turned into a bureaucracy

For most of Chicago’s history, immigrant education was built around a hard but simple bargain: When you came to America you were expected to speak the native tongue. It was not always gentle. It was, however, clear. The child adapted to the English-speaking school, and the family, parish, neighborhood, and classroom all pushed in the same direction. 

That older world is easy to caricature. It can sound like the gruff neighborhood command: “You come to America, you speaka da English!” Yet millions of children from Italian, Polish, Greek, Czech, Lithuanian, Jewish, and other immigrant families did learn English that way. Some failed, some muddled through, and some soared. It was a sink or swim mentality. At the very least it punctured the modern assumption that English immersion is educational malpractice. 

Today, Chicago Public Schools (CPS) operate in a very different legal and bureaucratic universe. The old sink-or-swim model is gone. English Learner (EL) services are no longer optional. Under federal civil rights law, state bilingual education rules and decades of court precedent, CPS must identify students with limited English proficiency and provide language support. Bilingual Education Act 

Carl Churchill, Douglas Belkin:

Colleges are rethinking test-optional admissions.

After a pandemic-era push to stop requiring standardized tests such as the SAT and ACT, some schools are bringing them back. Others are under pressure to do so. Here are five things to know about what’s happening with the SATs.

Most schools are test-optional, but lots of students still take the SAT

For years, the SAT was the gold standard of college-admission exams. Today, about 90% of colleges don’t require the SAT or ACT, according to FairTest, which advocates against the exams.

Even though most schools don’t require them, admissions officers often use submitted scores to assess candidates. The number of people taking the SAT has risen in recent years.

Teagan King

This is unsustainable at a time where our benefits just went up $14 million, we are being asked more and more to fairly compensate our employees, so our costs are not going to (decrease).

……

I just want this community to know that there’s greatness happening all over the place. Equal to that are challenges. There are people who might not feel they’re learning to their best abilities, who might feel like our data says that we have to do more, or who are feeling like schools or some environments are unsafe. That’s work we have to do. And what I’ve learned in my years of being a superintendent is that truly nothing happens by me alone, it’s the ability to work as a community.

——-

Early Literacy Screener Map.

More. Act 20.

3,887 Madison 4 year old to third grade students scored lower than 75% of the students in the national comparison group.

Madison taxpayers have long supported far above average k-12 tax & $pending. This despite our long term, disastrous reading results. May, 2026: 7,095 Staff for 25,003 students; $pending > $26k per student!

Madison Schools: More $, No Accountability

The taxpayer funded Madison School District long used Reading Recovery…

The data clearly indicate that being able to read is not a requirement for graduation at (Madison) East, especially if you are black or Hispanic”

A.B.T.: “Ain’t been taught.”

My Question to Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers on Teacher Mulligans and our Disastrous Reading Results

2017: West High Reading Interventionist Teacher’s Remarks to the School Board on Madison’s Disastrous Reading Results 

Madison’s taxpayer supported K-12 school district, despite spending far more than most, has long tolerated disastrous reading results.

“An emphasis on adult employment”

Wisconsin Public Policy Forum Madison School District Report[PDF]

WEAC: $1.57 million for Four Wisconsin Senators

Friday Afternoon Veto: Governor Evers Rejects AB446/SB454; an effort to address our long term, disastrous reading results

Booked, but can’t read (Madison): functional literacy, National citizenship and the new face of Dred Scott in the age of mass incarceration.

When A Stands for Average: Students at the UW-Madison School of Education Receive Sky-High Grades. How Smart is That?

Peggy Noonan:

All this culminated at the start of seventh grade when I met with a guidance counselor, who flapped through my record, sized me up—unkempt, ill-dressed—and told me I wouldn’t be on a college track, but that if I aimed high, cleaned up my act, got myself together, I had a chance to become a clerk in an office, a person who files things. This wounded me. I’m sure I made a joke—“I was thinking poet laureate”—but it cut because I had it in my head that somehow a person in a position of authority who knew things might see beyond the mess and mediocrity, spy some promise in me, hearten me. Save me.

Having been tagged a loser I went on, as children do, to make my loserdom official. We moved a lot, sometimes suddenly, winding up with the nine of us in a two-bedroom apartment over a candy store in Rutherford, N.J. My sister Cookie was older by a year and we blew off school together, wandering around and chain-smoking. She did her hair like Cher, loved the Shirelles and the Ronettes, fashioned herself as a hood. (Decades later it was she who called the day Donald Trump announced his candidacy and told me of his power.) I presented in a would-be collegiate style, I think to cheer myself up. I didn’t go to my high school classes, because I stayed up all night reading novels—Fitzgerald, Hemingway—and biographies. I’d sleep all morning, then creep out of the apartment when school was over and run back in banging doors, shouting to nobody, “I’m home!”

College wasn’t in the picture. On graduating high school I went to work in the world, commuting on a bus to Newark to a job as a clerk at the Aetna Insurance Co. on Broad Street. The next year three unhappy friends and I ran away, pooling our money for an old car and driving south until we reached Miami Beach. We got jobs as waitresses at the Lincoln Road Restaurant. It was near the auditorium where Jackie Gleason taped his weekly variety show, and his June Taylor Dancers used to come in for lunch. Once one came in and sat at the counter and we talked a long time about the news and life, and when I cleaned up after she’d gone she’d left a $20 bill under the saucer. Wow. My fellow runaway Kathy, working the same shift, ran over to say, “She almost left $100. She had it in her hand but hesitated!” Kathy thought I might be sad. No. It was one of the greatest moments in my life. I did have promise! A dancer for Jackie Gleason wanted to encourage it!

We returned to Jersey, I enrolled at Fairleigh Dickinson University at night and made up the classes I’d failed in high school, and at age 20 I was accepted to attend FDU full time during the day. I was a college student. And eager now, finally, to sit in a class and listen, absorb. I worked hard, did well, edited the school newspaper. In coming decades I went on to work as a writer for a radio station, then a network, then for a great president, now a great newspaper.

I’m saying what you already know: Never count anyone out. Don’t count yourself out. Don’t take the world’s appraisal of you and make it your own. Be aware of its appraisal—maybe the world has reasons for its reservations, maybe you should work on them. But maybe the world isn’t giving more than a cursory look; maybe it’s hardly looking at all. Even if it is, its estimation will likely lack a warmth of imagination. You may have to bring your own.

Stefan Collini:

Britain’s ‘world-leading’ university system is in deep trouble. There are, inevitably, conflicting diagnoses of the malady, but the indicators of deteriorating health are too ubiquitous to be ignored. When a substantial number of universities are in serious financial jeopardy, with some hinting at possible bankruptcy in the short term (according to the Office for Students, some 45 per cent of ‘higher education providers’ will face a deficit for 2025-26); when the viability of universities is heavily dependent on attracting large numbers of international students whose fees make up between a fifth and a third of their income and whose recruitment is vulnerable to the slightest twitch of governments’ anxieties about immigration; when nearly every week brings news of fresh closures of courses and redundancies among academics, especially in the humanities; when some of the subjects that have long been regarded as among the staple offerings of any university worthy of the name are now in danger of becoming extinct or confined to a handful of privileged institutions; when one in four UKphysics departments are thought to be at risk of closure and when research council funding of the physical sciences may in some cases be reduced by as much as 30 per cent in proposals that are said to threaten ‘generational destruction’ in those fields; when undergraduates are taught in very large groups, with limited opportunities for personal contact with an established member of academic staff and only the most minimal requirement to produce written work; when the bulk of undergraduate teaching in some departments is done by people on poorly paid short-term contracts with no possibility of career progression, a precariat shamefully exploited by cash-strapped universities; when there is a growing fury and sense of injustice among graduates (and their parents) who realise that the student loans they were compelled to take out, loans that are subject to punitive interest rates and whose terms are retrospectively variable, will condemn them to paying what is in effect a higher rate of taxation for almost their entire working lives; when all these laments have become so familiar that they simply elicit a weary shrug – then it becomes difficult to deny that something has gone badly wrong with higher education in Britain. (Or, at least, in England and, with significant variations, in Wales and Northern Ireland; Scotland, having retained a large measure of direct government funding for education rather than the fees system, has experienced some of these problems rather differently.)

——-

more.

Jo Ellison:

It’s hard to make the case for university as a place for personal development if it’s only serving to function as a jumped-up finishing school

The number of people enrolling in higher education is still hitting historic highs. Nearly 40 per cent of the UK’s 18-year-olds head into higher education, and Unesco’s first Higher Education Global Trends Report shows that the number of students enrolled worldwide has more than doubled during the past two decades, reaching 269mn in 2024. 

With AI haunting our future prospects, and the employment market becoming increasingly distressed, students graduating from college at the moment are joining a Hunger Games-style market in which the scant few jobs on offer are going to the very best. 

Does the degree hold any value? Sadly, it depends on where you go. A cursory glance through the successful pool of applicants to most junior jobs in most institutions will still reveal a bias towards those who went to the schools within the Russell Group or Ivy League. As university degrees become more widespread, estimations of their worth have diverged. Does an Oxbridge degree hold any value? It will certainly help if you want to work within my team. 

At best, university forestalls the inevitable horror of having to enter the workplace. It’s a chance to flex some independent muscles and develop a personality that isn’t a clone of ma and pa. University is less about one’s field of study (unless you want to end up in academia) but learning how to navigate human behaviour, take initiatives and maybe finesse some basic meals. That said, the cost is increasingly prohibitive, especially when factoring in things such as empty-flat summer rent. And it’s hard to make the case for university as a place for personal development if it’s only serving to function as a jumped-up finishing school.

Olivia Ireland, Bernd Debusmann, Iain Watson and Chris Graham

Farage, who reposted Vance’s remarks without comment, had argued the incident was the result of “two-tier policing”, citing anti-racism guidance issued by police bosses.

“Two-tier policing” is the claim that minority communities are treated preferentially because officers are worried about being accused of racism.

——-

Henry Nowak.

Byron Gilliam

In the first half of the 19th century, for example, the Midwest was so short of authentic banknotes that people knowingly accepted counterfeit ones. “This was a region that needed money,” Mihm writes, “and counterfeiters provided it.”

California, by contrast, was comparatively hostile to faked notes. Miners expected to exchange the gold they dug up for notes that were at least partly backed by precious metal. When $100,000 of Bank of Missouri notes were found to be counterfeit, an avenging group of miners chased the counterfeiter all the way to New York.

Paul Vallas

With Mayor Brandon Johnson now joining Chicago Teachers Union President Stacy Davis‑Gates and Vice President Jackson Potter in attacking Gov. J.B. Pritzker — calling him an “out‑of‑touch billionaire” and worse — will he have the courage to opt Illinois into the federal Tax Credit Scholarship Program that they oppose? That would be payback: sign on to a program the union vehemently opposes which would provide low‑ and middle‑income families with real money to improve their children’s education.

Davis‑Gates has been a relentless critic. During Pritzker’s vetting for a possible vice‑presidential pick, she questioned his commitment to public‑school children — particularly Black children — saying he was “continuing the tradition of denying funding for Black, brown, working‑class and immigrant kids in Illinois’ largest school district.”

Jackson Potter has repeatedly accused the governor’s administration of protecting billionaires and offering large corporate tax breaks while classrooms go wanting. Mayor Johnsonhas joined those critiques and added a personal swipe: he said the billionaire governor “doesn’t know what it’s like to open a refrigerator and, ain’t no food in it.

Matt Burgess:

We need to make hard decisions before they’re made for us. Part 2 (long overdue) of my series on how to (and how not to) reform higher education

In other words, academics are saying: “let us govern ourselves”, and our critics are saying: “we don’t trust you to govern yourselves because you’re not doing it”. 

So, academics can best defend shared governance by showing that we can actually govern ourselves.

Does that require agreeing with every charge the Trump administration and others have leveled against us? No. But it does require—at a minimum—enforcing the rules and standards that we already claim to be enforcing. Here are some specific suggestions.

Shelly Norden:

Universities and education groups push to embed students inside school board decision-making systems.

Parents across America are already battling school districts over curriculum transparency, gender ideology, DEI programs, anti-Semitism, and political activism in public education. Now a growing movement tied to universities and activist-aligned education groups is pushing to fundamentally change how public schools are governed by placing students directly into school board decision-making and reducing the influence parents have over public education.

Teachers College Columbia University and its School Board and Youth Engagement (S-BYE) Lab sit at the center of the movement. The organization openly states that it wants to “redesign school boards to be more democratic” and create what it calls a “functioning multiracial democracy” through public school systems. The lab focuses on “democratic innovation” through youth engagement and school governance.

The movement goes far beyond encouraging students to participate in civics classes or attend school board meetings. Teachers College promotes programs designed to give students direct influence over school board decisions involving budgets, curriculum, policy development, governance priorities, and institutional decision-making. The initiative also encourages participatory budgeting, student-led governance forums, civic activism simulations, and direct engagement between students and elected officials.

Governance advocates warn that each part of the model pushes schools further away from academics and deeper into political organizing. Participatory budgeting trains students to influence spending decisions and pressure school leaders over ideological priorities. Student-led governance forums place students inside policy discussions traditionally handled by elected adults accountable to taxpayers and voters. Civic activism simulations train students how to organize campaigns, apply political pressure, and influence institutional outcomes. Direct engagement between students and elected officials creates pathways for activist organizations and ideological movements to build influence inside local school systems through student networks.

The Crimson:

In 712 Harvard course offerings last year, every enrolled undergraduate received an A.

In another 532, A’s were common enough that the class would have violated the Faculty of Arts and Sciences’ newly approved grade cap — a policy that will soon limit top grades in most undergraduate courses to 20 percent of students, plus four more.

Together, those courses made up more than half of all undergraduate course offerings in a confidential grading dataset obtained by The Crimson, offering the clearest picture yet of how deeply Harvard’s grades have been compressed at the top — and how unevenly the faculty’s new cap will hit when it takes effect in fall 2027.

A Crimson analysis of more than 22,000 rows of course-level grading records found that A grades rose from roughly 44 percent of undergraduate grades in 2014-15 to about 63 percent in 2024-25.

But the rise was not spread evenly across the College.

In Arts and Humanities courses, roughly 78 percent of students received A’s last year. In Social Sciences, the figure was 62 percent. In the Sciences and the School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, A’s made up 57 percent and 56 percent, respectively.

Elizabeth Hernandez:

Between 2007 and 2025, births in the U.S. declined by 16%. In Colorado, they decreased about 8% during the same timeframe, according to Neal Marquez, projections demographer at the Colorado State Demography Office.

The Boulder-based Western Interstate Commission predicts a 12% decline in Colorado’s high school graduates between 2023 and 2041. A total of 60,387 Colorado students graduated in four years in the 2024-25 school year, according to state data.

Higher education officials have watched their pool of typical applicants dwindle little by little. Most have been in talks for years on how to pivot to stave off what education officials have collectively dubbed “the demographic enrollment cliff.”

In Colorado, many institutions have managed to keep a positive enrollment trajectory so far, but now they’re peering over the edge of the cliff, hoping they can incentivize enough new applicants with promises of affordability and resources.

Choose life.

Wall Street Journal:

The Board of Regents in May 2020 moved to scrap the university’s SAT/ACT requirement on the spurious rationale that tests discriminate against minorities. Gov. Gavin Newsom, who appoints most regents, had claimed the tests exacerbate “the inequities for underrepresented students,” even though a faculty senate report found otherwise.

Test scores “add substantially to UC’s ability to predict student success” beyond high school grades, especially for minority groups, the faculty report said. It stressed that the university “does not appear to use standardized test scores in a way that amplifies racial disparities.” Without test scores, admissions would hinge on inflated grades, extracurricular activities and essays.

Those warnings have borne out. The new faculty letter says that “for three consecutive years, 20-30% of UC Berkeley first-semester calculus students who participated in mathematical diagnostic testing displayed severe preparation deficits.” Drop standards, and learning mastery declines. Imagine that.

Emma Whitford:

Effective Friday, the existing Faculty Senate is dissolved. It already held an advisory-only role, but its replacement—the Presidential Academic Advisory Council—“is a shift from faculty-led governance to administratively controlled consultation,” the Auburn American Association of University Professors chapter wrote in a statement. The council will “provide advice and perspective, at the President’s request and direction, on matters related to academic policy, academic governance, and the academic mission of the University,” as well as “confidential” advice on other matters, according to the policy. The body may not issue any public statements on behalf of the university.

The council will comprise two faculty members from each college—one elected by the college’s faculty and one appointed by the president—as well as “additional members appointed by the President, who may include faculty or nonfaculty members whose expertise, institutional role, or perspective would assist the Council’s work,” the policy states. In making his appointments, President Christopher Roberts may consider “academic discipline, rank, tenure status, research activity, instructional experience, administrative experience, accreditation expertise, student-success responsibilities, institutional service, collegiality, and other factors.”

Mark Criley, a senior program officer in the department of academic freedom, tenure and governance at the AAUP, called the changes “the end of shared governance” at Auburn. 

Shakiyya Bland:

In recent years, particularly since the pandemic, countless news articles have bemoaned a crisis in math learning. Whether defined by introductory courses at Harvard University, math placement in the University of California or community college remedial courses, a consistent refrain is that students emerge from high school “profoundly underprepared” and opening access to math courses could mean “hurting students.” 

Stripped of careful phrasing, the logic is familiar: Some students are deficient, fixing them is costly, and enrolling too many of them threatens institutions. 

That is deficit thinking dressed in the language of stewardship. When an institution implies that certain students are the problem, it has already made a judgment about who belongs.

Consider what deficit framing erases. Imagine a first-generation student who graduates near the top of her class from an under-resourced high school in a rural district. She has taken every math course available to her through Algebra II, taught by a long-term substitute, from a textbook nearly a decade out of date. She arrives at a university, sits for a math placement exam, scores below the cutoff and is routed into non-credit remedial coursework that she may have to pay for out of pocket. It delays her progress and drains her financial aid. Within two years, she leaves without a degree. 

The institution calls this an outcome. The data suggests it was a decision made the day she sat for that test. But context is key.

The label “underprepared,” when used to disqualify students rather than support them, turns a snapshot of current performance into a verdict about their potential. Researcher Gloria Ladson-Billings argued that we should stop focusing on the so-called “achievement gap” and instead examine the “education debt” — a historical accumulation of disinvestment that shapes who gets access to strong instruction, advanced coursework, advising and college preparation. 

——-

21% of University of Wisconsin System Freshman Require Remedial Math

How One Woman Rewrote Math in Corvallis

Singapore Math

Discovery Math

Connected Math (2006!)

Math Forum 2007

Wall Street Journal:

From sea to shining sea, museums, concert venues, theaters, production companies and every other conceivable cultural group are fêting the land of the free this year. This collection of notable happenings, updated every week, will keep you up appraised of ways to join the celebrations.

Simon Calder:

»

1995: The Independent had a strict “no freebies” policy prescribed by founding editor Andreas Whittam Smith. So I was acutely aware of the cost of travel. The mid-Nineties saw some undoubted bargains – £179 for a Virgin Atlantic flight outbound from Heathrow to Los Angeles and back from New York JFK.

Yet within Europe, fares were stubbornly high. A questionably obtained student card eased the financial pain, but even so, London to Glasgow was a minimum of £100 return by air. Plenty of entrepreneurs had sought, unsuccessfully, to make flying affordable. So, when a fax arrived at the office of The Independent announcing a new carrier between Luton and Glasgow, beginning in November 1995, I paid it little heed.

The link between London and Scotland’s biggest city was conveniently carved up by Air UK, British Airways and British Midland. While easyJet promised fares as low as £29 each way, the business model seemed fatally flawed. You couldn’t buy through travel agents, only by phone – with the number emblazoned in orange on the plane.

Kyle Saunders:

Timur Kuran is a libertarian-leaning economist at Duke. His most-cited book, Private Truths, Public Lies, is about preference falsification: why people misrepresent their political views in public, and how those misrepresentations destabilize societies that depend on them. His second book, The Long Divergence, asks why the Islamic world fell economically behind Europe over six centuries and lands on an answer about institutional rigidity. He is not a man with a soft spot for the contemporary humanities.

Last month Kuran posted this:

“The humanities shine when they illuminate civilizational transitions, such as the spread of agriculture or industrialization. Now, as we navigate the uncertainties of AI-based existence, they should be drawing on their accumulated scholarship to help us understand the present.”

Worth taking seriously, because of who said it. Kuran is not a humanities partisan trying to defend his tribe. He is an economist/analyst who spends his career asking how institutions go bad and stay bad. When he points at a discipline that’s failing to do something he thinks it was built to do, the diagnosis carries a weight (at least it should, in my estimation) it wouldn’t from inside the humanities or from culture-war media.

What Kuran is pointing at is real. The humanities have done some of their most lasting work at moments of civilizational reorganization. Erasmus and the early modern humanists made sense of the printing press and the Reformation. The encyclopedists made sense of the industrial threshold. Hannah Arendt, Reinhold Niebuhr, Lewis Mumford, and Stephen Toulmin made sense of the post-war reckoning with industrial-scale violence and technological power. The work that came out of those moments is what most of us still read, decades or centuries later, when we want to understand how the present took its shape.

Institute for Reforming Government:

Implications for charter schools, private schools, and tax bills

Democratic candidates gathered for the Wisconsin Workers’ Forum for Governor on June 2, hosted by several unions. Former Lieutenant Governor Mandela Barnes, Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley, State Representative Francesca Hong, former Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation CEO Missy Hughes, Lieutenant Governor Sara Rodriguez, and State Senator Kelda Roys participated.

The moderator asked extremely specific questions with follow-ups, shining new light on where candidates would take Wisconsin education.

Here is what the candidates said.

Dairyland Sentinel:

When a state agency launches a massive new initiative to redefine what public education looks like, you would think they would want to brag about the people helping them build it. Transparency is usually the first card played when government officials want to build public trust in a brand new, statewide project.

Apparently, the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction missed that memo.

Last week, State Superintendent Jill Underly announced the creation of the Portrait of a Graduate framework. According to the department’s official press release, this initiative is meant to establish a shared vision of the skills and knowledge a student needs to succeed in the modern workforce. To do this, DPI claims it has assembled a diverse steering committee that includes workforce representatives, state agencies, and various Wisconsin employers.

Naturally, we wanted to know who those committee members are. It is a simple, standard question. If a business owner or industry group is helping steer the future of Wisconsin education policy, their names should be a matter of immediate public record. This is not highly sensitive intelligence; it is a roster for a public advisory committee.

Tyler O’Neil

The Southern Poverty Law Center raises money by presenting itself as the expert on combating “hate,” and then exaggerating “hate” to scare donors into ponying up cash.

The problem? The SPLC’s inflated demand for “hate” has long outstripped the supply. Thousands of donors expect the SPLC to prove there’s enough “hate” to justify their donations, and that often leaves the center scrambling to keep up.

A jaw-dropping Justice Department indictment, filed Tuesday, appears to reveal yet another way the SPLC tried to meet this demand.

The SPLC has a clearinghouse for hate, a “hate map” that claims to reveal the “infrastructure of white supremacy.”

The SPLC map has included old shopkeepers in the South who still support the Confederacy, but most Americans know people like that are irrelevant.

——-

F-30 wasn’t the only one. F-31 & F-32, KKK members, wanted out in 2010.

The SPLC bribed them to stay in the movement. These Fs used the $ to attend extremist rallies and to gain a leadership role.

SPLC reimbursed them for cross-burning materials.

——-

F-37, a member of the leadership chat for the Charlottesville rally in 2017, made racist posts under an SPLC employee’s supervision and arranged transport for others to attend the rally. SPLC paid this person $300K.

——-

Read this thread. I gave a possible identity to the SPLC plant in Charlottesville – and it’s someone who was central to organizing Unite the Right, and also talked about running over protesters before the rally.

I’m pretty sure I nailed it. There’s no one else in those transcripts who fits, especially after today’s revelations.

——-

Yet the field sources used the SPLC’s $ to:

1⃣Attend extremist rallies
2⃣Host rallies
3⃣Grow existing chapters
4⃣Create new chapters
5⃣Recruit individuals
6⃣Donate to extremist leaders
7⃣Purchase cross-burning material
8⃣Create racist paraphernalia
9⃣Pay living expenses

——-

Superseding Indictment Alleges SPLC Funded “Ku Klux Klan garments” and “Cross-Burning Events”
Asserts wide-ranging wire and bank fraud “to disguise the true nature, source, ownership, and control of the fraudulently obtained donated money the SPLC paid” to extremist group members SPLC supposedly was fighting.

——

More.

Further.

Josh Blackman:

Judge Eleanor Ross, who serves on the federal bench in Atlanta, engaged in multiple acts of misconduct. She carried on a secret affair with an Atlanta police department officer for nearly two years, repeatedly had loud sex in her chambers, lied about her trysts, and obstructed the investigation. Each of these actions warranted a public reprimand and an impeachment inquiry. But one of the more stunning allegations has flown under the radar: Judge Ross routinely signs judicial orders her law clerks prepare without even reading them. Indeed, it seems she never even talks about these cases with her clerks, so likely has no clue what she is even approving. Yet the council that reviewed this case found no misconduct. 

Let me tell you a not-so-well-kept secret: most judges let their law clerks do far too much. Take it from my personal experience. I clerked in a federal district court for two years immediately after law school. The judge I clerked for, who recently passed away, was a dedicated jurist and an honorable man, but he let his clerks have far too much autonomy. At the time, I was overwhelmed with how many important decisions turned on my immature judgment. In hindsight, I cringe at my mistakes that the judge did not catch. Judge Ross will likely lose her judgeship, either through resignation or impeachment. But the public needs to take a closer look at judges who have abdicated the judicial power to unknown law clerks.

The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeal’s Judicial Council, which reviews misconduct complaints, interviewed six of Judge Ross’s former law clerks. They explained that the judge’s “longstanding practice was to handle all criminal case work without law clerk assistance.” This choice makes some sense, as Ross was a former prosecutor. This work is also predictable. Virtually all federal cases wind up with plea bargains, so the most difficult work concerns calculating a defendant’s sentence. This sort of judgment will be based in large part on experience and judicial philosophy. The judge I clerked for would allow law clerks to make recommendations but he always calculated the sentence himself after considering all the evidence.

Atlas-Lean:

ATLAS is a Lean 4 library of textbook mathematics autoformalized by LLMs: informal statements and proofs translated into Lean code. It draws from undergraduate and graduate textbooks across analysis, algebra, geometry, topology, combinatorics, probability, statistics, PDEs, number theory, and theoretical computer science.

The goal of ATLAS is to provide reusable formal building blocks for future human- and machine-driven Lean formalization. This is an active effort: we are continuing to scale to more sources, curate the generated material, improve coverage and maintainability, and move the library closer to Mathlib conventions.

ATLAS was generated with AutoformBot, our autoformalization pipeline.

Stephen Bush:

In order to reverse the rise of “woke history”, pupils in England will, under a Reform government, have to study a radically new curriculum — or rather, a radically old one.

Under plans put forward by the party’s education spokesperson, Suella Braverman, pupils would have to cover the signing of the Magna Carta, the Wars of the Roses, the English Civil War, the Glorious Revolution, the Act of Union, the Enlightenment and Victorian Britain in a syllabus which would be at least 60 per cent devoted to “British” history. I take the view that there are no boring bits of history, and therefore no “wrong” answers on the curriculum. But I am baffled as to why only two out of three of England’s civil wars have made the cut, and indeed why it is that learning about them is meant to make you feel more patriotic afterwards. There are passages of history where we come out well, but Charles I’s wars of choice, or the republican experiments that followed him, are not among them.

Reform’s proposed history curriculum raises any number of questions, not least why “winning the second world war” is not higher up the list of worked examples of the UK’s patriotic history. Is it because Reform politicians or those in their orbit often seem to be agnostic about whether that one was an unalloyed good?

“Legal Process”

Vanderbilt report decrying State of Scholarship calls out Ed schools and social work research for serious problems:

“There is reason to believe that the problems we have identified in the core disciplines are significantly more serious in some of these allied areas”

——-

Early Literacy Screener Map.

More. Act 20.

3,887 Madison 4 year old to third grade students scored lower than 75% of the students in the national comparison group.

Madison taxpayers have long supported far above average k-12 tax & $pending. This despite our long term, disastrous reading results. May, 2026: 7,095 Staff for 25,003 students; $pending > $26k per student!

Madison Schools: More $, No Accountability

The taxpayer funded Madison School District long used Reading Recovery…

The data clearly indicate that being able to read is not a requirement for graduation at (Madison) East, especially if you are black or Hispanic”

A.B.T.: “Ain’t been taught.”

My Question to Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers on Teacher Mulligans and our Disastrous Reading Results

2017: West High Reading Interventionist Teacher’s Remarks to the School Board on Madison’s Disastrous Reading Results 

Madison’s taxpayer supported K-12 school district, despite spending far more than most, has long tolerated disastrous reading results.

“An emphasis on adult employment”

Wisconsin Public Policy Forum Madison School District Report[PDF]

WEAC: $1.57 million for Four Wisconsin Senators

Friday Afternoon Veto: Governor Evers Rejects AB446/SB454; an effort to address our long term, disastrous reading results

Booked, but can’t read (Madison): functional literacy, National citizenship and the new face of Dred Scott in the age of mass incarceration.

When A Stands for Average: Students at the UW-Madison School of Education Receive Sky-High Grades. How Smart is That?

Teagan King:

The district’s overall revenues and expenses would be roughly even, at about $706 million each. That represents a 5.6% increase in revenues from the current school year, largely boosted by higher property tax revenue generated from the referendums voters approved in 2024, and a 4.1% increase in spending.

The district is planning a $38.5 million increase in revenues from property taxes next school year, with $441.6 million from property taxes going toward the operating budget. Year to year, that’s up 9.5%.The school-based property tax levy will increase by 8.3%, bringing the school portion of the property tax bill for an average Madison home to $5,186.28, according to the proposed budget. It follows a 20.4% increase for the 2025-26 school year, which the report indicates was the largest in more than 30 years.

The report also said voters are likely to support future referendums, but they could grow tired of doing so while the tax levy continues to increase.

“The accumulating levy increases may dampen that enthusiasm over time. One important consideration for MMSD officials is whether and how to lobby for legislative changes that would increase state aid to the district and offset some of these local tax increases,” the report said. “District leaders may also look to offset some of their spending increases with cuts and changes similar to the decision to require employees to pay more for their health insurance in 2027.”

—-

Early Literacy Screener Map.

More. Act 20.

3,887 Madison 4 year old to third grade students scored lower than 75% of the students in the national comparison group.

Madison taxpayers have long supported far above average k-12 tax & $pending. This despite our long term, disastrous reading results. May, 2026: 7,095 Staff for 25,003 students; $pending > $26k per student!

Madison Schools: More $, No Accountability

The taxpayer funded Madison School District long used Reading Recovery…

The data clearly indicate that being able to read is not a requirement for graduation at (Madison) East, especially if you are black or Hispanic”

A.B.T.: “Ain’t been taught.”

My Question to Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers on Teacher Mulligans and our Disastrous Reading Results

2017: West High Reading Interventionist Teacher’s Remarks to the School Board on Madison’s Disastrous Reading Results 

Madison’s taxpayer supported K-12 school district, despite spending far more than most, has long tolerated disastrous reading results.

“An emphasis on adult employment”

Wisconsin Public Policy Forum Madison School District Report[PDF]

WEAC: $1.57 million for Four Wisconsin Senators

Friday Afternoon Veto: Governor Evers Rejects AB446/SB454; an effort to address our long term, disastrous reading results

Booked, but can’t read (Madison): functional literacy, National citizenship and the new face of Dred Scott in the age of mass incarceration.

When A Stands for Average: Students at the UW-Madison School of Education Receive Sky-High Grades. How Smart is That?

John Sailer:

Interestingly, the report immediately narrows its scope down to that last complaint, that scholarship has been overrun by political goals, distorting disciplinary standards and producing bad research.

…there are limits. If an astronomy department becomes an astrology department, deference would obviously be a bad thing. This raises the question of when outside scrutiny is warranted, and what that scrutiny should look like. (The report’s own stance here is v moderate.)

The State of Scholarship.

This report is addressed to university chancellors and presidents who are concerned about the state of academic scholarship in the humanities and the social sciences and who may wish, within their purview, to promote excellent scholarship in these vital fields. The charge to the committee, submitted in August 2025 and formulated by Daniel Diermeier, Chancellor of Vanderbilt University, and Andrew D. Martin, Chancellor of Washington University, reads as follows:

——

Greg Lukianoff:

Yes. It is an anti-intellectual practice to do an end run around reason and rigor by appealing to quasi-mystical political dogmas that cannot be challenged.

It replaces Liberal Science with something far easier and far older: substituting what must be true according to their own simplistic moral certainties for the harder discipline of asking whether their own political dogmas might be false.

Freddie deBoer:

Recently a bunch of young people have been using the term “point of view” in a way that’s unhelpful. I say unhelpful rather than wrong because I have zero interest in jumping into the grammar wars, which aren’t actually much of a war. Just about zero people out there are actually strict grammarians, and the collective essaying world has taken sides against “grammar Nazis” at a scale of at least 1000 to 1, so it’s a war against almost no human enemy. You see that with this whole POV business; there’s ten billion essays and tweets and YouTube videos defending the practice and like one guy on the bus who hates it, but we have to pretend that he’s the hegemonic force or whatever. It’s weird stuff, but the impulse ultimately has a clear source: fear of looking old.

The deal is that much of Gen Z (and “Gen Alpha,” which is the dumbest generational name ever devised) uses “point of view,” or “POV,” to mean simply “look at this,” rather than “this image or video is shown from the point of view of X,” the traditional usage. Apparently it’s all over TikTok in particular – a video will be labeled “POV: an elephant,” and what you see is an elephant and not something seen from the perspective of an elephant. “POV: you rollerskated for the first time” but it’s just video of the TikTok user rollerskating rather than rollerskating from the perspective of the rollerskater. You get the idea. This usage is unhelpful and impractical, if you ask me, whether or not we want to call it incorrect! As is so often the case with imprecision in language, this behavior gets rid of a very useful construction and puts in its place something we already could say in many different ways. As with turning “literally” into an empty intensifier often applied to metaphorical use, the mass meta-sanctimony of the anti-grammarian set on this issue has left the English language weaker than it was and called it progressive. And now here the NYT trots out a linguist to tell you that you’re a reactionary for maybe preferring the more useful version.

Scott Atlas:

Editor’s Note: Below is the keynote address of Dr. Scott Atlas at the Chicago Thinker’s 2026 American Identity Summit. Dr. Scott Atlas MD is an American radiologist, health policy scholar, and senior fellow at the Hoover Institution affiliated with Stanford University. Atlas served as a Special Advisor to President Trump and was a member of the White House Coronavirus Task Force in 2020.

Good morning! It’s great to be here at my training ground, my medical school alma mater, the University of Chicago—the highlight of my academic background. It’s great to be here among many friends and colleagues and to see the students here to talk about reforming higher education. The Thinker has some of the boldest students who are committed to freedom, regardless of pressure from their own professors and peers. It is true—this is the generation that is going to save the country. 

And it’s exciting to see a common theme emerging all over the country, including outside the United States: the need to reform institutions. Several months ago in London, Jordan Peterson’s Alliance for Responsible Citizenship (ARC) conference invited me to address the broader topic, “Can Institutions Be Reformed?” As many of you know, ARC is bringing together voices from all over the world to discuss how to reinstate and preserve the institutions and best values of Western heritage, particularly the West’s unique commitment to freedom. 

The sudden emergence of this theme is also something to ponder. Why, at this moment in history, is it particularly important to consider how America’s institutions—here, colleges and universities—should be reformed, or whether they can even be reformed? 

After all, for decades we have been aware that our institutions were failing: editorialized, dishonest journalism; wasteful, corrupt government; and colleges and universities increasingly abandoning their essential purpose of fostering the free exchange of ideas and critical thinking in favor of agenda-driven social advocacy, particularly advocacy unbalanced toward the left. 

My answer? The tipping point finally came in 2020. COVID—the pandemic—fully exposed the massive institutional failure that could not be denied: the most tragic, the most blatant hijacking of freedom and breakdown of leadership in free societies in our lifetimes. 

Yet, oddly, the pandemic fiasco—the spark of this heightened focus on institutional reform—remained invisible at that weeklong ARC conference, unmentioned by dozens of speakers except for me. It was the elephant in the room, just as the truth about the death and destruction from the lockdowns remains missing from virtually all of America’s political discussions, including those in this administration and on university campuses today. Why has the page been turned with no accountability? Something to contemplate. 

Simon Kuper:

It feels as if they were only born half an hour ago, but my enormous twin sons are now 17 and preparing (I hope) for the French end-of-school exams, “le bac”. Come September, they should follow their sister to university in the UK, leaving my wife and me in an empty nest in Paris.

While you’re in the thick of parenthood, it seems eternal. Family life is repetition: the nappies, bedtime stories, football games and thousands of dinners. But as Nicholas Lemann wrote, it’s only a “(long) season of life”, and for us it’s ending. I remember what our cohort of new parents expected from parenthood 20 years ago, when my daughter was born. Instead we were ambushed by reality, which took on forms we hadn’t imagined.

My parenting peers in the early 2000s were mostly educated urbanites (commenters, please fill in own epithet), who thought we could shape our children through our individual decisions about parenting. The cohort’s chief metric — inevitably a point of unspoken competition — was hours spent doing childcare. The dominant ambition was to speed children up the educational ladder, teaching them to read aged three, etc. Looking back at that era, just before the financial crisis, there was still a frank admiration for success. People badly wanted their kids to make it.

Cavalier Johnson, Howard Fuller, Gregory Wesley and JoAnne Anton

• Milwaukee’s fourth-grade reading scores are among the worst for large urban districts in the nation.
• A coalition of public, charter, and private schools was formed to train educators in the science of reading.
• Wisconsin Act 20 mandates science-based literacy instruction and allocates state funding for it.
• The Milwaukee Reading Coalition says the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction is needlessly delaying the release of funds.

In Milwaukee, nearly three out of four fourth graders cannot read at a basic level. According to the 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) — the nation’s most respected measure of student achievement — only 9% of Milwaukee’s fourth graders scored as proficient in reading, and the city posted the largest decline in fourth-grade reading scores among major urban districts since 2019. Of the 25 large urban districts tested, only Detroit performed worse than Milwaukee.

Behind those numbers are thousands of children being failed by a system that knows this, and yet refuses to act. Wisconsin has the widest achievement gap between Black and White students of any state in the country — a distinction it has held for decades. Black fourth graders in Wisconsin score an average of 50 points below their White peers on the NAEP reading assessment. In Milwaukee, where Black students make up a significant share of enrollment, this gap represents not just a statistic but a generational crisis.

Litong Deng

The percentage of failing grades in multiple UC Berkeley computer science classes in spring 2026 is significantly higher than past semesters and marks a departure from the department’s grading guidelines.

Instructors point to students’ increased reliance on AI, lack of mathematical preparedness and understaffing as potential contributing factors.

According to Berkeleytime, 35.3% of CS 10 students and 10.6% of CS 61A students received F’s in spring 2026. In spring 2025 and spring 2024, the percentage of F’s did not exceed 10% for either class. The electrical engineering and computer sciences department’s grading guidelines state that 7% of students in lower division courses, including CS 10 and CS 61A, should receive D’s and F’s.

Zachary Small:

The Education Department is finalizing guidelines for an earnings test that would punish nearly half of all graduate programs in visual arts, music and performance based on the low income of recent alumni, according to the government’s calculations.

The proposed guidelines apply to all university programs, and institutions whose alumni fail to meet them twice in three years could lose their ability to enroll students using federal loans. Those students would most likely need to transfer to other programs or quit their education. According to experts, that would lead to a sharp decrease in enrollment and the likelihood of school closures.

For master’s degree programs, the agency would calculate the earnings of alumni four years after graduation to see whether they earn more than the median salary for working adults aged 25 to 34 who have a bachelor’s degree. Previous tests measured all programs against the salary of working adults with high school diplomas — a lower threshold for universities to pass.

“They are taking a DOGE approach to education,” said Tom Eccles, who runs the Center for Curatorial Studies at Bard College, adding that most universities were just learning about the guidelines. “They are deciding what the metric is, as though there were an objective way to measure the value of an arts education.”

Most students pursuing an arts degree know that becoming the next Picasso or Lady Gaga is a long shot, and that an arts degree is unlikely to have an immediate payoff. A preliminary analysis of the economic data released by the Education Department shows that many of the country’s top arts programs would not pass the revised earnings test.

Anthony Bradley:

I have watched an evangelical college close up close. Not from a distance, not through press releases, but from inside the institution. I have seen the faculty meetings where optimism slowly curdled into anxiety. I have seen the administrators who genuinely loved their students continue planning programs for a future that had already expired. I have seen the students who had no idea they were studying on borrowed time.

When The King’s College in Manhattan shut its doors in 2023, the explanations came quickly: compromised leadership, financial mismanagement, and poor decisions. These explanations were not entirely wrong. But they were convenient, because they located the problem in people rather than in the system. They allowed everyone else to feel safe. If this just was a leadership failure alone, then competent leadership could prevent it from happening again.

Here’s the hard truth folks: it can’t. And until the evangelical world is willing to say that plainly, people will be blind to what is happening nationally. 

Here it is plainly: the evangelical college system that emerged after World War II is structurally finished.Not declining. Not under pressure. It’s a wrap y’all and we’re going to see many Christian colleges close over the next few years. What we are watching across the country is systemic unraveling. The conditions that made these institutions possible have changed, and most of them are not coming back.

This is a structural argument, more so than an anecdotal one. Every declining system produces visible outliers. Late-stage contraction often concentrates enrollment in a shrinking number of institutions as weaker ones disappear. The presence of thriving schools does not refute this analysis some would argue that actually confirms it. Growth inside a collapsing pipeline is not evidence of health. It is evidence of consolidation, mergers, and shifts in brands.

By Christopher Weaver and Anna Wilde Mathews:

The billing abuses run wide. Aetna said the number of investigations that found likely fraud or abusive billing by autism-therapy providers in its private-plan business shot up by 300% between 2024 and 2025—and is on track to rise by another 50% this year. 

The issues detected by the insurer’s probes include poor documentation, billing for multiple services for the same hour and claiming to provide care at home addresses that don’t really exist, said Katerina Guerraz, Aetna’s chief operating officer.

“We’re seeing just a massive inflation,” especially when providers are not in-network, Guerraz said. 

In bills reviewed by The Wall Street Journal, a daily charge for one child reached more than $30,000. 

Maciej Cieglowski:

Our intelligence level, cognitive speed, set of biases and so on is not predetermined, but an artifact of our evolutionary history.

In particular, there’s no physical law that puts a cap on intelligence at the level of human beings.

A good way to think of this is by looking what happens when the natural world tries to maximize for speed.

If you encountered a cheetah in pre-industrial times (and survived the meeting), you might think it was impossible for anything to go faster.

But of course we know that there are all kinds of configurations of matter, like a motorcycle, that are faster than a cheetah and even look a little bit cooler.

But there’s no direct evolutionary pathway to the motorcycle. Evolution had to first make human beings, who then build all kinds of useful stuff.

Ira Stoll

The Sanders plan is also a good case study of how universities and foundations are feeding left-wing ideas into the political system. Sanders acknowledges that he got the idea from two law professors, Jeremy Bearer-Friend of George Washington University Law School and Sarah Polcz of UC Davis School of Law. Bearer-Friend is a former aide to Warren, who herself is a former law professor. He’s also written for the Roosevelt Institute, a think tank funded by the Hewlett Foundation, George Soros’s Open Society Foundations, and the Ford Foundation that published a Bearer-Friend paperproposing a $1 trillion tax to fund racial reparations. (”As with any new trillion-dollar tax, we should expect litigation. But the power to tax has been a part of our Constitution since our founding and is not on its face legally dubious.”)

Bearer-Friend and Polcz published their article on December 30, 2025, in the Columbia Journal of Tax Law, proposing, “a unique in-kind tax payment structure that would require firms with ownership of AI to remit equity shares to the public.” Their article doesn’t specify a rate. “The actual rate to be adopted will largely be a political question,” it concedes. It does say the ideal rate “will provide the adequate level of public voice in corporate decisions to address public harms of AI” and “will provide a sufficient profit interest to compensate injured workers and creators,” while only “minimally” crowding out private investment.

In April, Polcz posted to social media a version of the law journal article that was adopted for The Hill, a Capitol Hill publication that’s a frequent fallback resort for opinion pieces written by academics that have been rejected by higher-profile outlets. “Know any lawmakers looking to tax AI? We’ve got a proposal for them,” she said, with remarkable candor about the motivation of the legislators.

———

An Oligarchy of Old People

———-

“Seize the means of production”? What would the Middle Eastern Studies graduate do if she got hold of a semiconductor fab? Could she and Ayatollah Mamdani run an oil refinery after reading Chemical Engineering for Dummies? How many New York City progressives could keep even the simplest modern factory in operation?

Dave Mass & Rindala Alajaji:

An EFF analysis of millions of searches of Flock Safety automated license plate reader (ALPR) data by police has uncovered a troubling pattern: in the absence of a warrant requirement to search ALPR databases, law enforcement agencies have moved beyond specific investigations to use these surveillance networks for virtually any whim.

Our findings suggest that the absence of a warrant requirement has fostered a culture of unrestricted access to sensitive location data, allowing agencies to leverage that data beyond the scope of specific criminal investigations.

As a refresher: Law enforcement agencies lease or purchase camera systems from Flock Safety and then mount them by the side of the road and at intersections to document every vehicle that passes, including the plate, make, model, color and distinguishing characteristics, along with the date, time and location of where it was seen. 

Law enforcement’s talking points—often scripted by the company itself—trumpet their role in solving high-stakes crimes. But the data reveals a different story. What they’re not saying is that ALPRs are also frequently used for extremely low-level investigations, such as verifying whether a student lives within a particular school zone. In some cases, police have even used this tech to conduct employment background checks and investigations into loud music complaints. Recently, a motorcyclist was even targeted for simply holding a cell phone while riding.

Max Planck Institute:

New study by Emanuela Campisi (University of Catania) and Anita Slominska and Asli Ozyurek (Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics) reveals that Italian and Dutch adults adapt their hand gestures in remarkably similar ways when explaining new concepts to children.

New study by Emanuela Campisi (University of Catania) and Anita Slominska and Asli Ozyurek (Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics) reveals that Italian and Dutch adults adapt their hand gestures in remarkably similar ways when explaining new concepts to children.

When adults teach children something new, words are only part of the story. A new cross-cultural study shows that adults from different cultures instinctively modify their gestures in similar ways to help children learn, suggesting that spontaneous human teaching may rely on a shared, deeply rooted communicative strategy.

Researchers found that although Italian adults used more gestures overall than Dutch adults, both groups increased the use of visually rich, two-handed gestures when demonstrating unfamiliar logic puzzles to children. The findings highlight how humans naturally adapt communication to support young learners, regardless of cultural background.

Jo Ellison:

Lately, I’ve been spending time with Bunny Mellon. The American Listerine heiress, society swan, gardener and horticulturist Rachel Lambert Mellon, nicknamed Bunny by her mother, was born in New York in 1910. Although she was from a wealthy background, her worth became stupendous upon her second marriage, to the banking heir Paul Mellon, with whom she became one of the most prolific art collectors of the 20th century. He bought Monets. She got Rothkos. Plus baubles, baskets and dozens of porcelain cauliflowers. When she died at the age of 103 in 2014, the sale of her possessions brought in $218mn.

I have been reading her biography, by Meryl Gordon, because I am intrigued by her influence on the world of luxury. Mellon was one of the most important patrons of the era, the tastemaker of her day. In particular, she shared an intense — and rumoured romantic — attachment with the Tiffany designer Jean Schlumberger, from whom she commissioned an estimated 140 jewels. These included a golden sunflower, beaded with emeralds and set in a terracotta plant pot (1960), and the first Bird on a Rock brooch — one of the US jeweller’s best-known designs.

Paul Alivisatos:

As a next step in the University of Chicago’s overall approach to artificial intelligence (AI), the University is partnering with Anthropic to provide Claude Enterprise for all academics and staff starting in July, and for all students before the fall term. Claude Chat, Cowork, and Code will be made available to the campus community. Spanning the domains of research, education, and operations: these are powerful tools that are being made available to help individuals find ways to improve our pursuit of knowledge, our commitment to teaching students how to think independently, and the ability of our staff to support this work efficiently. Access will be granted to the newest versions of Anthropic’s tools—for those who choose to use them—with improved integration with university resources and tools and more data protection than is available with private accounts.

This is a time of rapid change due to the advent of AI, and the University has been thoughtful in navigating it. Indeed, there is inspiration to be drawn from our faculty’s report on AI and Education that calls on us to be skeptical, ethical, and ambitious when it comes to AI, while remaining grounded in the habits of mind and standards of judgment that define this university. In some cases, it is clear that AI tools can be brought to bear with the desired results. In others, we will do better by retaining our previous approaches or even developing new policies to expressly protect against misuse. In all cases, our highest priority in making these tools available is to center our respect and commitment to each individual human being who is part of this community.

Linda Kinstler:

Last spring, newly admitted students to San Jose State University received an unusual video message from the institution’s president, Cynthia Teniente-Matson. Her caramel curls were tucked behind her shoulders, her hands clasped neatly at her torso. Dressed down in a royal blue hoodie, she appeared composed and approachable. “Congratulations on your admission,” she said. “At S.J.S.U., you’ll have opportunities to dive into the technologies shaping the world today, and redefine what’s possible for tomorrow.”

This was not, in fact, Teniente-Matson addressing the new class, but her brand-new custom A.I. avatar. “I’m thrilled to share this special moment with you,” the avatar said. “It’s only fitting, isn’t it? After all, technology is a cornerstone of what makes San Jose State University such an incredible place to learn, innovate and grow.”

The avatar is one feature of S.J.S.U.’s A.I. Everywhere strategy, which was formally announced in the fall of 2025 and aims to integrate the technology across campus life. Teniente-Matson devised A.I. Everywhere as part of the California State University system’s broader A.I. Initiative, introduced in February 2025. Anchored by a $16.9 million deal with OpenAI, the initiative provides a total of 500,000 licenses of ChatGPT.edu to be issued to all students, faculty and administrators. At the time, this was the largest single-institution deployment of ChatGPT in the world, billed as an attempt to turn C.S.U. — the biggest four-year public higher education system in the United States, comprising 22 distinct campuses and educating 1 out of every 10 workers in the state — into “the nation’s first and largest A.I.-powered public university system.” (The terms of the deal stipulate that OpenAI may not train its model on data from the C.S.U.)

At San Jose State — the oldest public university in the California State University system — evidence of the shift toward A.I. is evident across campus. The university now has an A.I. librarian, and its main library features a new A.I. Center for Civic and Social Good. The business school runs an A.I. boot camp for high school students; the campus career hub is sponsored by Adobe; A.I. literacy training is an orientation requirement and, last year, an A.I. agent helped coordinate commencement logistics.

BBC:

This is a privacy problem that can cost you money. Among the biggest customers for car data are insurance companies, and they’re using it to charge some people higher prices. But there’s no telling where your information is going. Some car companies admit they sell your data, but they don’t have to say who’s buying. That’s to say nothing of the fact that you might find it a little creepy. Most consumers, experts say, have no idea it’s even happening. 

“People would be shocked at the number of data points that their car collects and transmits to other people, either the manufacturer or third-party applications,” says Darrell West, a senior fellow in the Center for Technology Innovation at the Brookings Institute in Washington DC. “It basically means your life can be recreated almost on a second-by-second basis.” 

Feeling uncomfortable yet? A federal law is about to increase the amount of data your car can gather about you. It will soon require American car companies to install infrared biometric cameras and other systems to scan your body language, track your eyes or other aspects of your behavoiur to detect whether you’re too drunk or tired to drive. But it will also open up a whole new trove of data about your health and your habits. There are no rules limiting what the car companies can do with that information. 

Ko Envangilst

Specialized small models are their strategy.Mistral showed several examples where small, fast and focused models outperform the big general-purpose ones when it comes to energy efficiency and speed: Document AI for OCR (used by the EU Patent Office to do large scale OCR), Voxtral for multilingual voice (powering Amazon’s Alexa+ in Europe), and Robostral for industrial robotics with ASML. And also in token-heavy agentic applications, speed and efficiency are becoming as important as raw capability.

Sovereignty and on-prem are their selling points. BNP Paribas runs Mistral models on-prem for KYC in Belgium, with sensitive data staying within the bank’s walls. Abanca is using agent orchestration to handle sensitive customer information at a huge scale (more than 1 million customers in their app). For European companies in regulated industries, this is a good alternative to relying on US hyperscalers.

A talk that was a bit out of the ordinary and that I really enjoyed was about ancient papyrus documents: a research team from the Austrian Academy of Sciences finetuned a coding LLM by Mistral (Codestral) to read tiny snippets of millennia-old discarded papyri that had sat unpublished for decades. This work helps make a collection of 180,000 documents found in the Egyptian desert accessible, a job that would have taken more than 2000 years without AI. A beautiful exampleof how AI can also help the humanities.

Brian Rosenberg

Imagine if the Mayo Clinic suddenly announced that it planned to field a professional football team, or if the Dallas Cowboys broke ground on a hospital, or if Pfizer launched a liberal-arts college. Well, no need to imagine, really. Simply enter into the world of the contemporary American research university.

Tim Harford:

What is the value of high-quality, trustworthy official statistics? Given the number of things that statistical agencies measure, we might expect that they have attempted to put a number on this too. In fact, they have often been rather coy. A UN report, “Promoting, Measuring and Communicating the Value of Official Statistics”, published in 2018, was packed with qualitative ideas about how statistics were useful: they were said to build trust in government, improve decision-making, promote equality and “help us understand who we are, have been and are becoming”. All reasonable enough, but cost-benefit analysis was thin on the ground.

A cynic might suggest this near silence speaks volumes. Maybe official statistics have little value? That was the radical view of Sir John Cowperthwaite, who was the financial secretary of Hong Kong throughout the 1960s, when it was a rapidly growing, laissez-faire British colony. Cowperthwaite thought the value of official statistics wasn’t merely minimal, but negative: he told the economist Milton Friedman that he didn’t collect economic data, because it would only encourage the Whitehall variety of mandarin to interfere.

In context, Cowperthwaite’s position was understandable: few economies were more at risk of clumsy meddling than Hong Kong, a colonial possession pursuing a libertarian path on the opposite side of the world from soft-left imperial rulers. Still, there are at least two weaknesses in his argument. The first is the hope that ignorance might restrain the interventionist impulses of governments. It might simply make those interventionist impulses clumsier. The second is the unexamined premise that only a government might find official statistics useful.

Vicky Yang:

Between 1985–2023, MIT’s faculty grew 9%. Administrative staff grew 189%. 📈 Why? In new @PNASNews paper, we use dynamical system model to show administrative bloat can emerge without empire-building–just from well-intentioned problem-solving gone awry

——-

What Leads to Administrative Bloat? A Dynamic Model of Administrative Cost and Waste

Svetlana Jitomirskaya And Zvezdelina Stankova:

“At UC San Diego, the number of freshmen failing to meet high-school math standards grew nearly 30-fold between 2020 and 2025. By fall 2025, 1 of 12 entering students was placed into remedial math to learn material taught in elementary and middle school”

——

more.

——

21% of University of Wisconsin System Freshman Require Remedial Math

How One Woman Rewrote Math in Corvallis

Singapore Math

Discovery Math

Connected Math (2006!)

Math Forum 2007

Tyler Jagt:

The generational collapse in literacy is measurable, persistent, and likely to get worse.

Six weeks into the term, I assigned my rhetoric and writing students a 20-page article. It was the same length I had assigned for five years and the same length I had read without complaint as an undergraduate a decade ago. Not one student finished it.

When I asked why, a student answered honestly: It was too long, and she kept losing track of what the paper was about. This was not a remedial class: These were students who had cleared the admissions process and written essays good enough to get them here. Yet a routine academic reading assignment had defeated them.

———-

more.

———-

Early Literacy Screener Map.

More. Act 20.

3,887 Madison 4 year old to third grade students scored lower than 75% of the students in the national comparison group.

Madison taxpayers have long supported far above average k-12 tax & $pending. This despite our long term, disastrous reading results. May, 2026: 7,095 Staff for 25,003 students; $pending > $26k per student!

Madison Schools: More $, No Accountability

The taxpayer funded Madison School District long used Reading Recovery…

The data clearly indicate that being able to read is not a requirement for graduation at (Madison) East, especially if you are black or Hispanic”

A.B.T.: “Ain’t been taught.”

My Question to Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers on Teacher Mulligans and our Disastrous Reading Results

2017: West High Reading Interventionist Teacher’s Remarks to the School Board on Madison’s Disastrous Reading Results 

Madison’s taxpayer supported K-12 school district, despite spending far more than most, has long tolerated disastrous reading results.

“An emphasis on adult employment”

Wisconsin Public Policy Forum Madison School District Report[PDF]

WEAC: $1.57 million for Four Wisconsin Senators

Friday Afternoon Veto: Governor Evers Rejects AB446/SB454; an effort to address our long term, disastrous reading results

Booked, but can’t read (Madison): functional literacy, National citizenship and the new face of Dred Scott in the age of mass incarceration.

When A Stands for Average: Students at the UW-Madison School of Education Receive Sky-High Grades. How Smart is That?

T. Keung Hui:

Thousands of teachers and supporters gathered in Downtown Raleigh on Friday for the NCAE “Kids Over Corporations” May Day march demanding higher pay and increased school funding. (The video has been updated to correct the name of NCAE President Tamika Walker Kelly). By Robert Willett | Ethan Hyman| Travis Long 

The North Carolina Association of Educators has the power to bring thousands of protesters to Raleigh, but a new report also says the state has one of the weakest teacher unions in the nation.

A new report this week from the Fordham Institute ranked North Carolina 48th in teacher union strength nationally out of the 50 states and the District of Columbia. The report found that North Carolina had the second-largest drop in union membership since 2012, dropping from 49% of the state’s teachers to 21%.

The conservative think tank found that teacher union membership has dropped in 45 states and the District of Columbia since its last state-by-state look in 2012.

“Though it may sound fanciful to education reformers in Chicago, where the teacher union is as militant and powerful as ever, overall the data suggest that teacher unions are weaker than they were a decade ago,” according to the report.

NCAE, the state affiliate of the National Education Association, says it’s growing in strength. Tamika Walker Kelly, NCAE president, said the group has added 1,000 new members since its May 1 march in downtown Raleigh.

——

Related: WEAC

WEAC: $1.57 million for Four Wisconsin Senators

Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty

In Episode 10 of the “If You Can Keep It” Podcast, we shift our focus to America’s classrooms to examine the current state of education in Wisconsin and beyond. We dive into why the traditional “assembly line” model of public schooling may be out of date, how the birth rate collapse is driving school consolidation, and the balance between public education and school choice.WILL President Rick Esenberg is joined by Dr. Will Flanders, the architect behind WILL’s most impactful reports and data-driven research on academic achievement. They look ahead at a new model for schools, exploring the technological impact of AI, and the “Southern Surge” in literacy to see what lessons Wisconsin can learn from unexpected success stories across the country.

———

Early Literacy Screener Map.

More. Act 20.

3,887 Madison 4 year old to third grade students scored lower than 75% of the students in the national comparison group.

Madison taxpayers have long supported far above average k-12 tax & $pending. This despite our long term, disastrous reading results. May, 2026: 7,095 Staff for 25,003 students; $pending > $26k per student!

Madison Schools: More $, No Accountability

The taxpayer funded Madison School District long used Reading Recovery…

The data clearly indicate that being able to read is not a requirement for graduation at (Madison) East, especially if you are black or Hispanic”

A.B.T.: “Ain’t been taught.”

My Question to Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers on Teacher Mulligans and our Disastrous Reading Results

2017: West High Reading Interventionist Teacher’s Remarks to the School Board on Madison’s Disastrous Reading Results 

Madison’s taxpayer supported K-12 school district, despite spending far more than most, has long tolerated disastrous reading results.

“An emphasis on adult employment”

Wisconsin Public Policy Forum Madison School District Report[PDF]

WEAC: $1.57 million for Four Wisconsin Senators

Friday Afternoon Veto: Governor Evers Rejects AB446/SB454; an effort to address our long term, disastrous reading results

Booked, but can’t read (Madison): functional literacy, National citizenship and the new face of Dred Scott in the age of mass incarceration.

When A Stands for Average: Students at the UW-Madison School of Education Receive Sky-High Grades. How Smart is That?

Steve Yegge:

It turns out interviewing was broken long before I learned the trade, and despite the many attempts to band-aid it, it’s still broken today. It has managed to survive in spite of that. But it is finally dying on its own. People are a bit unclear on what’s next, so we’ll talk about some of our options.

But it’s not an easy path I bring you, no silver bullet. Remember that, grasshopper, when you get to the end and come back to yell at me.

Two Big Dogs

Back at Amazon, we had this elite group, the Bar Raisers, which I hear is similar to a role at Microsoft they call As-Appropriate (AA). In both cases, a trusted interviewer (the BR/AA) is assigned to every interview loop, and has the power to veto any unqualified people the interviewers try to sneak through. I was a BR, and also part of “Bar Raisers Core”: a small group Bezos and Dalzell tasked with defining the BR role itself, choosing new bar raisers, training them, and reporting on the program’s efficacy.

The BR and AA roles are a tacit acknowledgement that you can’t trust your interview teams to make good hiring decisions. Which even more broadly, suggests that if every single interview loop needs a babysitter, then it is a flawed process. But we were doing our best.

Wall Street Journal:

Union leaders like to pitch “solidarity” among their members, but it’s often a political fiction. So it was last week when the rank-and-file of the Chicago Teachers Union rejected a union ballot question seeking a dues increase. Take that, comrade.

CTU president Stacy Davis Gates and vice president Jackson Potter told their colleagues that, while votes are still being counted, “the results seem clear—a majority of CTU members have elected not to implement the proposed dues restructuring at this time.” The memo, reported by the Chicago Policy Center, says that with some 80% of schools counted, 60% or so of members had rejected the plan.

The union tries to explain away the rejection by noting the CTU has been busy and that “even with 72 wins the ’96 Bulls still lost 10 games.” Why insult Michael Jordan and Scottie Pippen?

The CTU, one of the most left-wing unions in the nation, had sought the restructuring to “make our dues more equitable.” But members understood the change would have meant snatching up to $800 a year more from their paychecks.

Eleanor Olcott:

China is overhauling the world’s largest surveillance network with advanced AI, giving the state more automated powers to track people, analyse behaviour and predict potential unrest in real time. 

An FT analysis of more than a dozen procurement documents and interviews with people familiar with the contracts found that local governments across China were deploying new AI-powered surveillance systems as Beijing pushed police forces towards so-called predictive policing. 

The upgrades mark China’s most significant push in years to modernise a surveillance apparatus built a decade ago that authorities already use extensively to monitor the public, reduce street crime, suppress dissent and manage social stability. 

While Beijing’s surveillance state has long been touted as cutting-edge, its systems have become constrained by ageing hardware, fragmented software platforms and limited AI functions. 

It is now investing in new generations of AI-enabled cameras and software that can interpret scenes, identify patterns of behaviour and retrieve footage using written prompts, sharply reducing the need for manual police review. 

Ashlea Ebeling:

In the Lyon family’s case, big tax benefits are at stake. Ed died in 2019, when rules let people take minimum distributions from inherited retirement accounts over their lifetimes, allowing the balances to grow tax deferred for decades.

Under federal law, employers are generally required to pay out workplace retirement accounts to a surviving spouse, or the last recorded beneficiary if the spouse has signed a waiver forgoing the funds. In most cases, these designations trump what’s spelled out in a will or trust.

That can result in protracted legal fights among competing heirs.

In one recent case, for instance, a man’s $1 million-plus 401(k) went to an ex he had split from decades earlier instead of his brothers, because her name was on a 3×5 card. In another, an electrical engineer’s four children were listed as the designated beneficiaries for his $3 million 401(k), but his new wife’s spousal rights took precedence and she got the money.

Muriel Blaive, PhD:

The greatest intellectual failure of the Covid years was not that experts and intellectuals made mistakes. Mistakes were inevitable in a crisis marked by fear, uncertainty, incomplete knowledge, and real danger. Governments faced difficult choices. Scientists worked with imperfect data. Citizens had to act without knowing what would come next. No serious person should pretend that the pandemic presented simple decisions. The failure was different: it came afterward.

Having claimed extraordinary moral authority during the emergency, many of the intellectuals, experts, journalists, academics, and commentators who helped define the meaning of the crisis have shown remarkably little interest in examining that authority once the emergency ended. They were willing to speak in the name of science, reason, solidarity, responsibility, and public morality. They were indeed willing to divide the social world into the responsible and the irresponsible, the enlightened and the benighted, the rational and the dangerous. Yet now that the consequences of the Covid response have become clearer, many of the same figures appear eager to declare the matter closed. We are told that Covid is behind us. The world has moved on. There are new crises, new wars, new elections, new emergencies, new objects of anxiety. Why reopen old divisions? Why relitigate decisions made under pressure? Why continue arguing about a crisis that has passed?

The answer is simple: because the crisis has not passed in the only sense that matters historically. Covid is not behind us if its consequences remain unexamined, if emergency practices altered the relationship between citizens and institutions, if children lost years of education and social development, and if loneliness, distrust, surveillance, censorship, bureaucratic overreach, and social fragmentation became normalized. It is not behind us if the people who claimed authority during the crisis have not yet reflected on how they used it.

———

Waiting for an analysis of the long term costs of taxpayer supported Dane County Madison Public Health “mandates”

Svetlana Jitomirskaya, Zvezdelina Stankova:

In the midst of the Covid pandemic, the University of California system in 2020 abolished the requirement that applicants submit an SAT or ACT score. That was contrary to the unanimous recommendation of the Standardized Testing Task Force, a faculty group that had studied the issue for more than a year. This temporary policy became permanent under pressure from the state of California. 

As mathematics professors at UC Berkeley, we have seen the results: a yawning preparation gap among students that undermines the goals of access and equity for which the change to a test-blind admissions system was made.

———

: 21% of University of Wisconsin System Freshman Require Remedial Math

How One Woman Rewrote Math in Corvallis

Singapore Math

Discovery Math

Connected Math (2006!)

Math Forum 2007

Teagan King:

As the Madison School District mulls its first districtwide cellphone use policy, some of Madison’s high school teachers and parents are pushing for stricter rules, particularly in the high schools.

The current proposal would set a bell-to-bell phone ban for elementary and middle school students and an off-and-away approach for high schoolers.

Wisconsin’s public school districts are required to create a cellphone policy restricting use during instructional time by July, under a state law passed in October. Madison’s proposed policy classifies “instructional time” as classes, assemblies and labs.

Under the district’s proposed policy, which would cover “wireless communication devices” including smartphones, e-readers and smartwatches, kindergarteners through eighth graders would be prohibited from accessing devices during the school day, including free times like lunch and recess.

The policy would be less strict with high schoolers, who would be prohibited from phone use during instructional time but could use their devices during passing periods and lunch. It would require a phone storage system such as a schoolwide system or boxes in individual classrooms.

———

More.

Chris Rickert:

A Dane County judge on Monday dismissed a child sex crimes case against a former Sun Prairie School District dean of students who was sentenced in April to 18 years in federal prison.

Robert Gilkey-Meisegeier, 31, was sentenced on April 28 for creating child pornography after he pleaded guilty to soliciting and receiving a video of a partially clothed Sun Prairie West High School student.

The Dane County District Attorney’s Office on Monday morning moved to dismiss its state case alleging similar behavior by Gilkey-Meisegeier and Judge Nicholas McNamara signed an order to do so.

The state’s July 28 criminal complaint charged Gilkey-Meisegeier with 13 counts of possession of child pornography and two counts of child sexual exploitation.

According to that complaint and police testimony in his case, Gilkey-Meisegeier victimized two students at West and downloaded images of a third girl whose nude photos he found on the internet.

In the federal case, the U.S. Attorney’s Office said Gilkey-Meisegeier groomed multiple female students and put photos of students’ faces on hundreds of nude photos of adults he found on the internet. He also had a nude photo of a 12-year-old girl on his phone, a sentencing memorandum says.

Also charged in connection with Gilkey-Meisegeier’s case is his former boss, former West Principal Jennifer Ploeger.

——-

More.

Matthew J. Slaughter and David Wessel:

One road leads to historic opportunity. Taking this route requires continuing to discover and harness innovations like artificial intelligence and clean tech to boost productivity and to yield widely shared prosperity and, thus, to restore confidence in the American dream. The other road is potholed by further widening of the chasm between economic winners and losers and narrowed by walls that the U.S. is building to block the global flows of products, capital, people and ideas that the nation promoted for decades after World War II.

Americans increasingly voice anxiety and skepticism about the forces of innovation, globalization and competition. Too many have not experienced, or do not expect their children to experience, the growth in income, wealth and opportunity they consider adequate—relative to their memories of earlier decades, and relative to those at the top of the income distribution, and relative to their aspirations.

Three questions confront American capitalism at this crossroads, the resolution of which will shape the lives of future generations. Will America deliver economic opportunity to more of its people—or will the gap between the extraordinarily successful and struggling widen? Will America continue building walls to the world—or will it build new bridges? And will America strike the right balance between competition’s creative destruction and the government’s regulatory guard rails—or will it tilt too far in one direction or the other?

Jackson Woodward:

Public records turned up by The Ellis Collective, a student-led research group, have revealed that the UC system shared data collected by automated license plate readers at multiple campuses with U.S. Customs and Border Protection and other federal agencies, in apparent violation of state law.

The collective also raised concerns about the possibility that UC Berkeley, which maintains data-sharing agreements for its system of six ALPR cameras, may have shared data that could have potentially wound up in federal hands.

In California, sharing data collected by ALPR systems with out-of-state agencies is illegal and could incur fines of up to $2,500 per instance of illicit sharing.

Reports from ALPR provider VehicleManager at UC Riverside and UC Merced show that data collected on campus was forwarded to “CBP – NTC,” an acronym for U.S. Customs and Border Protection’s National Targeting Center.

UC Office of the President spokesperson Stett Holbrook did not respond to a request for comment on the apparent violation of state law.

Justin LaHart:

“Young people with college degrees are more likely to be employed, they are more likely to be earning money,” said Hershbein.

Among young people who don’t have bachelor’s degrees, there is a larger share who are sitting out—meaning, not even looking for work. The Labor Department doesn’t count them in the unemployment rate. Rather, the unemployment rate includes only people actively looking for work.

Hershbein found that in the first quarter the labor-force participation rate—the share of the population either working or looking for work—averaged 75.9% for people whose educations span high school through associate degrees. That was down from 77.1% in the first quarter of 2019. Meanwhile, the participation rate for young people with bachelor’s degrees was 86.7%, up from 85.7%.

So it looks as if the narrowing gap in the unemployment rate for young college graduates and their less-educated peers has come about because the college crowd is participating more actively in the labor market while others are moving to the sidelines.

Adam Ellwanger

One of my most memorable experiences as a college student was an insult I received from my professor. I had missed an exam due to work, and I asked him if I could make it up on another day. He reluctantly agreed. But when the day for the make-up arrived, I forgot about it. I needed an excuse: if I got a zero, I’d fail the course. I should have told him the truth and asked for mercy. But I lied. I told him that I had to work again. To my surprise, he looked at me and said, “If your work interferes with college, then you shouldn’t be incollege.”

I was offended (which is ridiculous, since I had lied). His remark struck me as “classist” and “exclusionary”—words I wouldn’t have used at the time. How much students are required to work in college depends on their family income. Should people be excluded from higher education because they can’t afford to study full-time? What an elitist! 

The thing was that I didn’t have to work much in college. My parents made sacrifices to pay for my tuition, room, and board. They didn’t give me any discretionary money, so I had to work some. But about ten hours a week at the library was enough to keep the drinks flowing and a pack of cigarettes in my pocket. 

Cyril Hedoin

This is not completely new. The “empirical turn” of economics has been well documented for quite a while now. It is explained by a conjunction of factors: the low- hanging fruit of economic theory has largely been picked, access to large datasets has been democratized, and computational power has been exponentially increasing. These factors have contributed to raising the opportunity costs of theoretical innovation to such a level that it now hardly pays off for junior economists to specialize in theoretical economics. However, what Cowen is describing is more than that. He’s describing a process whereby economists are progressively forgetting the marginalist roots of their discipline, roots that are still taught in introductory economics classes. It is a process in which economists are substituting machine-learning methods to build incredibly complex models (up to 360,000 factors, as Cowen documents) for economic—marginalist— reasoning based on basic concepts such as supply and demand and opportunity cost. In a way, we seem to be back to the old “measurement without theory” debate of the 1940s, but in a radically different context with more access to data and more computing power.

Katie Baker:

On this day a year ago, I was feeling pretty despondent. The 8th grade Social Studies STAAR test preliminary results had just been released, and I felt like I had done my students a disservice. While 75% of my students had reached Approaches (passed), only 37% had achieved Meets (on grade level), and even more demoralizing merely 16% accomplished Masters (above grade level). The state of Texas established this three tier system of grading for its yearly exam since the establishment of the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness test. Earlier in the spring of 2025, I had watched the Steplab Documentary, Great Teaching, Unpacked, and knew I wanted to employ certain aspects of the teaching within my own classroom. However, after receiving my results, it no longer felt like a choice, it was a necessity. 

To give the reader a little background, the 8th Grade Social Studies test is one that Texas students historically have struggled to pass since its inception in 2013.

While my scores last year were better or equal to the state average, I knew I had to do a better job of planning, asking questions, creating lessons and activities that mirrored the learning goals for each unit and would mimic the type of thinking needed to digest a question and decipher the best answer. In other words, I needed to grow my students’ knowledge and make it more durable.

Kiran Pfitzner

Thomas Carlyle famously claimed that “The history of the world is but the biography of great men.” In his view, history only really “progressed” when a “great man” through his actions ushered in a new epoch. Napoleon was the archetype for this model, a man who seemingly came from nothing to leave an indelible mark on world history. This model places extreme focus on individuals and thus on elite politics. The theory does not account for mass politics or leave room for the histories of those far from the levers of power. The clear deficiencies of a focus on “great men” led to its abandonment in favor of a broader approach to history, more interested in historical forces than in personalities. This historiographical turn led to the exploration of many important and previously neglected areas, yet “history from below” came with problems of its own. By emphasizing the role of structural forces, it deemphasized the role of individuals. With this approach, the course of history begins to appear inevitable. If it was the social and political forces of the French Revolution that made Napoleon successful, the logical conclusion is that it would have made no difference to the course of history should he have, say, suffered a fatal stroke in 1801, a premise few would accept. It is clearly untrue when applied to specific cases. Not only who ends up in power, but the specific decisions they make are deeply consequential. Who would really contend that the 20th century would remain unchanged had Hitler been killed in WWI?

The synthesis position is what I call here the “mediocre man” theory of history. The idea of this mediocre man theory is that history is not just shaped by great men or by mass sociological forces that make individual irrelevant. Instead, while it is shaped by structural forces, it is also shaped by ordinary people who end in positions of extraordinary importance. Sometimes those individuals have vision and the character to try to impose that vision on the world and constitute the “great” figures of history. Others are complete incompetents you wouldn’t trust to run a lemonade stand. As su, history is not shaped by the talented alone and mundane failures may be as consequential as grand successes. Dilettante monarchs neglect crucial reforms, awkward diplomats reinforce prejudices, military thinkers become set in their ways, etc. These idiosyncratic, average figures shape history not necessarily any less than their more talented counterparts. 

The Globe & Mail:

That should have been the starting point for the media in May, 2021, when the Tk’emlúps te Secwépemc First Nation first issued a press release announcing the “confirmation of the remains of 215 children of the Kamloops Indian Residential School” through the use of ground-penetrating radar that identified subterranean anomalies.

The media, including The Globe and Mail, did not initially scrutinize, much less challenge, that assertion. The initial headlines and stories in the media simply stated as fact that the remains of 215 children had been found. Many of those early stories, including in this newspaper, made reference to “mass graves” (a historically fraught phrase that does not appear in the Tk’emlúps 2021 press release).

Perhaps it will be proven, some day, that there are hundreds of unmarked graves at Kamloops. But it was not proven to be true in May, 2021. It is not proven to be true today.

Jordan Schachtel:

Something curious is happening in town halls and zoning meetings across America. From suburban Maryland to the Arizona desert, from Wisconsin’s statehouse to California’s San Gabriel Valley, the same pattern keeps repeating: residents show up worried about water use, power demand, or noise from a proposed data center—and standing next to them, megaphones in hand, are organizers from Code Pink and a Marxist-Leninist political party headquartered in Washington, D.C.

Share

The Party for Socialism and Liberation (PSL) has quietly become one of the most visible forces in the rapidly escalating war on American AI infrastructure. By a conservative count, PSL chapters have led or organized anti-data center protests in at least nine to ten distinct campaigns since late 2025. The Dossier found a significant presence in Prince George’s County, Maryland; East Charlotte, North Carolina; Tucson; Springfield, Illinois; Madison and Milwaukee; St. Louis; the Puente Hills; Atlanta’s DeKalb County; and northern Minnesota, among others.

Jackson Walker:

According to Forward Literacy, however, some 150 Wisconsin school districts and charter schools appear to be failing in the execution of early literacy remediation plans, which lay out exactly how parents will be notified and what steps will be taken to help students.

While schools are supposed to alert parents when new testing data is released, executive director Katie Kasubaski said the information is often merely uploaded to schools’ internal grading systems. Often, she said, parents either can’t access these or aren’t taught how. This, she said, leads parents to go uninformed about key deficiencies in their child’s education.

Instead of being instructed on how to find their students’ data, Kasubaski told Badger Institute “some parents are unaware.”

“Parents were technically notified but just didn’t know to look in the system for the scores,” she said.

Even the scope of how much information parents are missing isn’t clear. Kasubaski compiled a list identifying nearly 150 school districts and some charter schools as not meeting the law’s requirement that they publicly post their early literacy remediation plans detailing how they ensure that struggling readers progress toward reading proficiency and communicate that information to families.

———-

Early Literacy Screener Map.

More. Act 20.

3,887 Madison 4 year old to third grade students scored lower than 75% of the students in the national comparison group.

Madison taxpayers have long supported far above average k-12 tax & $pending. This despite our long term, disastrous reading results. May, 2026: 7,095 Staff for 25,003 students; $pending > $26k per student!

Madison Schools: More $, No Accountability

The taxpayer funded Madison School District long used Reading Recovery…

The data clearly indicate that being able to read is not a requirement for graduation at (Madison) East, especially if you are black or Hispanic”

A.B.T.: “Ain’t been taught.”

My Question to Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers on Teacher Mulligans and our Disastrous Reading Results

2017: West High Reading Interventionist Teacher’s Remarks to the School Board on Madison’s Disastrous Reading Results 

Madison’s taxpayer supported K-12 school district, despite spending far more than most, has long tolerated disastrous reading results.

“An emphasis on adult employment”

Wisconsin Public Policy Forum Madison School District Report[PDF]

WEAC: $1.57 million for Four Wisconsin Senators

Friday Afternoon Veto: Governor Evers Rejects AB446/SB454; an effort to address our long term, disastrous reading results

Booked, but can’t read (Madison): functional literacy, National citizenship and the new face of Dred Scott in the age of mass incarceration.

When A Stands for Average: Students at the UW-Madison School of Education Receive Sky-High Grades. How Smart is That?

Julie Jargon:

“Catching people doing embarrassing things has been going on for some time, and this is the more recent iteration of that,” says Catherine Bradshaw, a professor and senior associate dean for research at the University of Virginia.

School cafeterias are a common place for bullying to occur, she says, because the student-to-staff ratio is much higher than in a classroom. Bradshaw, who studies children’s mental health and bullying prevention, has been collecting data on 25,000 students. When asked where at school they’ve been bullied in the past month, 14% of elementary students and 18% of both middle- and high-school students reported it happening in the cafeteria.

Eating in a classroom

Recent graduate Nihar Patel hadn’t eaten lunch in the cafeteria at his Fairfield, Ohio, school since his freshman year because of lunch-shaming. He says he personally was never a target, though. One of his good friends was biting into a turkey sandwich when she noticed a flash: A group of other girls had taken her photo and posted it to the school’s Class of 2026 Snapchat page.

“She stopped eating at school,” 18-year-old Patel says, explaining that his friend didn’t want to talk about it but gave him permission to. “I know she’s always had body issues.”

Brian Potter:

Elon Musk calls the ratio of the final cost of a product to the cost of its raw materials the “idiot index.” A high idiot index suggests a highly inefficient process with a lot of wasteful operations that could be dramatically improved. A low idiot index suggests a process with much less room for substantial improvements. (It was allegedly the high idiot index of rockets that convinced Musk he could beat existing aerospace companies and that SpaceX was worth pursuing.)4

Armed with this concept, let’s look at the cost breakdown of a typical US single-family home, courtesy of Craftsman’s National Construction Estimator. The chart below shows the hard costs of construction: what it takes to put up the actual, physical building.

Jason Locasale:

The problem is that the erosion of academia did not stem from a lack of conservative viewpoints. It came from an administrative takeover and the corporatization of universities. Bureaucracies expanded. Administrators accumulated power. Scholarship, research, and teaching became secondary. The same administrators continue moving from institution to institution, getting promoted along the same career track while outsiders, independent thinkers, and the strongest scientists are marginalized.

Conservatives should not assume that changing the values statement changes the institution. The values statement was never the institution.

Rory Truex:

The Semester That Shook My Faith as a Professor

As I write this, my students are taking an in-person exam on Chinese politics. Three hours, closed book, no computers, pencil and paper. It’s Saturday morning. I am sitting outside a lecture hall, and they are emerging, slowly, with cramped hands, glad to be done with the test and the semester.

——

More.

Sherman Criner

In a new research brief, The Pell Institute for the Study of Opportunity in Education found that only 44 percent of American high school students expected to earn a bachelor’s degree in 2022, down from 72 percent in 2002. The study also revealed a parental gap among high school students, with only 33 percent of first-generation students aspiring to a bachelor’s degree in 2022, compared to 60 percent two decades earlier. What are Americans, particularly those concerned about the state of higher education, to make of these findings? Are they just one of many societal indicators of an “empire in decline,” or are they more localized signs of a defect in the American system of higher education?

To answer this question, one must first understand that this skepticism is not exactly borne out in the decisions of these young Americans. Data on immediate college enrollment rates of American high school completers—provided by the National Center for Education Statistics—demonstrates a fairly constant trendof high schoolers enrolling in college from 2002 to 2022. Though it is true that 3.2 percent fewer high school graduates immediately enrolled in college from 2002 to 2022, these numbers are rather deceptive. 

“ai” weekly:

What does adversarial use look like? You treat the AI output as a first draft from a smart-but-overconfident junior engineer. You don’t reject it reflexively and you don’t accept it wholesale. You interrogate it.

Here’s a prompt pattern I’ve baked into my actual workflow:
Here's the solution you proposed: [paste output] Now argue against it. What are the edge cases this doesn't handle? What assumptions did you make that might not hold in a production system? What would you change if you knew this code would be read by a senior engineer in a security audit?

Run that after any non-trivial AI-generated solution. What comes back is almost always useful — missed error states, implicit assumptions about input shape, security surface area that got glossed over. And critically: you are now thinking alongside the tool, not just consuming its output.

That loop — generate, interrogate, revise — is where judgment lives. It’s where you stay sharp.

Owen Yingling:

Today, the demonic vice of the old is not that they are hard and demanding on the youth — instead they do not demand enough from us, and they cannot quite believe that we have not lived up to the little they have demanded. They think too well of our generation.

Take the infamous photograph of a UCLA student showing off a ChatGPT window at graduation. What exactly does it mean? There are a million silly articles and think-pieces that unwittingly engage with it at the most charitable level: the student is showing off how he used ChatGPT to cheat on his essays, complete his final project, whatever, in order to graduate. Cheating on examinations is not particularly interesting or new. “Perhaps,” these pieces seem to chide in a stern parental voice, “the schools need to really crack down on AI because it makes cheating so much easier.” This is a cozy and noble sentiment that conflates a difference in kind with a difference in degrees. I do not think anyone over the age of 23, even if you are a teacher, graduate student, or professor, understands the extent to which AI usage affects every appendage of the university system.

The prevalence of AI use on college campuses, particularly at “elite” universities, is a cancer on our culture that threatens to turn a generation of promising young Americans into a class of drooling morons, and it will grotesquely disfigure, if not destroy, the university as an institute in every way that it is imagined — as a sacrosanct humanist project, as a moral training ground, or even as a vulgar sweatshop for job training.

I did not really notice the sing-songy cadence in the voice of one of my professors until my friend pointed it out: “Do you think he’s writing his lectures with Chat?” I am a tired and lazy student. The senior slump has started a quarter too early for me. “Who cares,” I thought.

Douglas Belkin:

University commencement speeches used to send graduates into the world with a boost of optimism and a dollop of advice. Now the events have become a political minefield.

Georgetown University’s law-school speaker stepped aside, the school wrote in a letter Wednesday, after students challenged his support for Israel. At South Carolina State, a rescinded speaker invitation ignited a DEI fight that now threatens the school’s funding.

At Utah Valley University, where a gunman killed conservative activist Charlie Kirk last year, the commencement speaker considered wearing a bulletproof vest under her gown—before pulling out altogether. New York University colleges have limited student speeches to prerecorded remarks.

Political violence, clashes over race and diversity, and geopolitical tensions have put many Americans on edge. Now that friction is spilling into commencement, a ceremony long reserved for good cheer.

Schools are generally steering away from partisan speakers but threading the needle is tough, said Robert Shibley, a lawyer at the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression. The underlying threat of violence, including a recent gunman at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner, “has given schools an excuse to use safety concerns as a kind of catchall to do what they want.”

John Psmith:

Math from Three to Seven: The Story of a Mathematical Circle for Preschoolers, Alexander Zvonkin (Moscow Center for Continuing Mathematical Education, 2007).

To me, one of the greatest historical puzzles is why the Cold War was even a contest. Consider it a mirror image of the Needham Question: Joseph Needham famously wondered why it was that, despite having a vastly larger population and GDP, Imperial China nevertheless lost out scientifically to the West. (I examined this question at some length in this review.) Well, with the Soviets it all went in the opposite direction: they had a smaller population, a worse starting industrial base, a lower GDP, and a vastly less efficient economic system. How, then, did they maintain military and technological parity1with the United States for so long?

The puzzle was partly solved for me, but partly deepened, when those of us who grew up in the ‘90s and ‘00s encountered the vast wave of former Soviet émigrés that washed up in the United States after the fall of communism. Anybody who played competitive chess back then, or who participated in math competitions, knows what I’m talking about: the sinking feeling you got upon seeing that your opponent had a Russian name. These days, the same scenes are dominated by Chinese and Indian kids. But China and India have large populations — the Russians were punching way about their weight, demographically speaking. Today, those same Russians are all over Wall Street and Silicon Valley and Ivy League math departments, still overrepresented in technical fields. What explains it? Are Russians just naturally better at math and physics?

When I related these questions to an Ashkenazi-supremacist friend of mine, he immediately suggested that “maybe it’s because they’re all Jewish.” (I’ve noticed that the most philosemitic people and the most antisemitic people sometimes have curiously similar models of the world, they just disagree on whether it’s a good thing.) My friend’s question wasn’t crazy, since there are definitely times when asking “were they all Jewish?” yields an affirmative answer. But in this case I had to disappoint him with the knowledge that many of these Russian math and chess superstars were gentiles.2 What’s more, by the ‘60s and ‘70s the Soviets had an entire discriminatory apparatus dedicated to keeping Jews out of the scientific establishment, so it would be impressive indeed if they were the foundation of its success.

Another possible explanation actually hinges on the relative poverty of the Soviet Union. Assume there are a lot of people out there with natural mathematical talent, but who given their druthers would major in underwater basket-weaving instead. The United States, because it’s so wealthy, can afford to “waste” a huge proportion of our talented population on humanities, arts, and other stuff that doesn’t involve you sitting in the school library until 3am. In other words, not going into a technical field is a form of luxury, which America can afford to consume. The Soviets, rather like the Chinese today, were forced by their underdog status to allocate human capital more efficiently (and had the authoritarian means to do so by force if necessary). This theory is related to the curious fact that, on average, the more feminist your society, the fewer women there are in math and science — which makes total sense if you assume that on average women are good at math but uninterested in it.

Miranda Dunlap:

Wisconsin Department of Workforce Development officials say whether the program continues or grows depends on if districts get on board and sponsor trainees to join up. But district leaders say a major hurdle is the cost — a key appeal of an apprenticeship is the employer paying them for the time they spend learning, but many public schools are already strapped for cash. Some want more funding tied to the program. 

“(It’s) stalling a little bit,” said Trent Sorensen, a Fox Valley Technical College dean. “We don’t have any (students) coming in for the fall. … There’s plenty of time, but it’s not taking off like it did in other states, and it’s simply because of the funding.”

A new way to train teachers

Wisconsin schools struggle to find enough teachers needed to lead classrooms — a problem largely fueled by poor retention and new workers moving to other states after graduating.

In 2024, Congress came through with some assistance: $570,000 in federal funds earmarked for establishing a teacher apprenticeship program in Wisconsin. 

Officials from DWD, the Department of Public Instruction, the Wisconsin Technical College System, and two universities teamed up to debut the pilot in January 2024. They praised the “earn-while-you-learn” approach to establishing a pipeline of workers: Districts could guarantee they’d have future teachers, while also filling lower-skilled jobs in the meantime. 

Brad Stulberg: 

A popular podcaster recently said drinking a few glasses of wine “ruined the next three days of his life.”

He specified he “didn’t get drunk,” but “got worse sleep that night” and said that when he looked at his wrist-worn device it messed up his score and “dopamine system or whatever, the cortisol” and he podcasted worse as a result.

Y’all—this optimization stuff can make you super fragile.

Before I go any further, an important disclaimer: alcohol is not good for you, especially if you are someone who struggles to stop after a drink or two. If you have a substance-use disorder or family history of substance-use disorders then a few drinks can absolutely ruin your week (or worse). There is nothing wrong with choosing to abstain for any reason at all. And yes, of course, getting drunk can derail a day or two.

But that’s not what this post is about.

Rather, it’s the latest example in a long line of internet optimization culture: eat this way, sleep that way, wake at this time, do that single exercise, follow this guru, take that supplement… This content is more about the performance of being great than the actual pursuit of greatness itself. It can even lead to anxiety.

Clayton Burns:

This is staggering and unbelievable, but Harvard has done nothing:

… Amanda Claybaugh, Harvard’s dean of undergraduate education and an English professor, told me last fall. She was one of several teachers who described an orientation toward the present, to the extent that many students lost their bearings in the past. “The last time I taught ‘The Scarlet Letter,’ I discovered that my students were really struggling to understand the sentences as sentences—like, having trouble identifying the subject and the verb,” she said. (The End of the English Major in The New Yorker.)

How would these chronic grammar problems be solved by the SAT? Garber has no sense.

Pamela Paul:

Brandon Webb is talking the way parents do when their kids aren’t around—tallying their strengths and foibles, failures and wins, and the extent to which his own shortcomings as a father may have contributed.

Much of this self-appraisal is detailed in his tenth book, “Puddle Jumpers: Powerful Mental Techniques from a Navy SEAL Performance Coach and Father of Three,” which comes out next week.

About halfway into the conversation, over Zoom from an Airbnb in the French Alps, it becomes clear that two of those kids, Jackson, 24, and Madison, 21 (both pseudonyms used in the book), have been flitting in and out of the room the whole time. They occasionally pop on screen to fact-check or elaborate on their father’s responses to questions.

“This was the most fun and fastest book I’ve ever written,” Webb, 51, says. The author of the memoir “The Red Circle” and “The Killing School: Inside the World’s Deadliest Sniper Program,” never imagined he’d write a parenting book. “I cried three or four times while writing.”

What made him cry? “Just these vulnerable moments with my kids,” he says. Madison failing to pass her purple belt test in Taekwondo. His son Tyler (also a pseudonym), now 19, getting kicked off the basketball team. The letter Jackson wrote to his parents explaining why he was going to the prom despite being grounded over an incident the family dubbed “Operation Weed.”